Reduced prefrontal and temporal processing and recall of high “sensation value” ads

Abstract

Public service announcements (PSAs) are non-commercial broadcast ads that are an important part of televised public health campaigns. “Message sensation value” (MSV), a measure of sensory intensity of audio, visual, and content features of an ad, is an important factor in PSA impact. Some communication theories propose that higher message sensation value brings increased attention and cognitive processing, leading to higher ad impact. Others argue that the attention-intensive format could compete with ad's message for cognitive resources and result in reduced processing of PSA content and reduced overall effectiveness. Brain imaging during PSA viewing provides a quantitative surrogate measure of PSA impact and addresses questions of PSA evaluation and design not accessible with traditional subjective and epidemiological methods. We used Blood Oxygenation Level Dependent (BOLD) functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging (fMRI) and recognition memory measures to compare high and low MSV anti-tobacco PSAs and neutral videos. In a short-delay, forced-choice memory test, frames extracted from PSAs were recognized more accurately than frames extracted from the NV. Frames from the low MSV PSAs were better recognized than frames from the high MSV PSAs. The accuracy of recognition of PSA frames was positively correlated with the prefrontal and temporal, and negatively correlated with the occipital cortex activation. The low MSV PSAs were associated with greater prefrontal and temporal activation, than the high MSV PSAs. The high MSV PSAs produced greater activation primarily in the occipital cortex. These findings support the “dual processing” and “limited capacity” theories of communication that postulate a competition between ad's content and format for the viewers’ cognitive resources and suggest that the “attention-grabbing” high MSV format could impede the learning and retention of an ad. These findings demonstrate the potential of using neuroimaging in the design and evaluation of mass media public health communications.

Mass media campaigns to promote smoking cessation among adults: an integrative review

“…One forced-exposure study found better performance on a recognition task and on psychophysiological measures of central cognitive processing after exposure to more extreme loss-framed messages than after exposure to less extreme and gain-framed messages 29. One study identified an advantage for low MSV on accuracy and response time,28 while another forced-exposure study found the impact of MSV on self-efficacy and beliefs depended on the sensation seeking level of participants 36. This study also found there was no effect of argument strength on beliefs and intentions 36.…”

Spectral EEG frontal asymmetries correlate with the experienced pleasantness of TV commercial advertisements

“…Nowadays, researchers are attempting to investigate the signs of the brain activity correlated with an increase of attention, memory, and emotional engagement during the observation of commercial advertisements [18,22]. In fact, indirect variables of emotional processing could be gathered by tracking variations of the activity of specific anatomical structures linked to the emotional processing activity in humans, such as the pre-and frontal cortex (PFC and FC, respectively, [11]).…”

A Multilevel Analysis of Antimarijuana Public Service Announcement Effectiveness

“…However, several recent studies have found interactions where the theoretically predicted effects of a given message variable are conditional upon other variables (Kang, Cappella, & Fishbein, 2006;Lang & Yegiyan, 2008;Langleben et al, 2009;. Specifically, two important message features in many persuasion theories are (1) the strength of arguments within the message, and (2) the degree to which a message elicits physiological arousal.…”