“…While alternative strategy use has been favoured in previous studies as an explanation for unimpaired performance on tasks thought to require mental imagery by aphantasics (Jacobs et al, 2018;Keogh et al, 2021;Zeman et al, 2010), none until now have used probabilistic mixture modelling to investigate the visual fidelity of their memory representations, which should be particularly sensitive to the strength of visual imagery. Alternative probabilistic mixture models to the one used here can be applied to continuous report data (e.g., Bays, 2014), but two-component models describe this type of data well and have previously been used to separate long-term memory retrieval success and precision (Brady et al, 2013;Cooper et al, 2017Cooper et al, , 2019Harlow & Yonelinas, 2016;Korkki et al, 2020Korkki et al, , 2023Richter et al, 2016;Stevenson et al, 2018;Sutterer & Awh, 2016). Moreover, it should be noted that the current results did not change when a model-free measure of object memory performance, raw angular colour deviation, was analysed.…”