Recruiting general practitioners and older patients with multimorbidity to randomized trials

Abstract

Background Older patients with multimorbidity are under-represented in experimental research. Objective To explore the barriers and facilitators to general practitioner (GP) and older patient recruitment and retention in a cluster randomized controlled trial (RCT). Method This descriptive study uses qualitative and quantitative data from a cluster RCT, designed to evaluate the effectiveness of a medicines optimization intervention. The SPPiRE cluster RCT enrolled 51 general practices and 404 patients aged ≥65 years and prescribed ≥15 medicines. Quantitative data were collected from all recruited practices and 32 additional practices who were enrolled, but unable to recruit sufficient participants. Qualitative data were collected from purposive samples of intervention GPs (18/26), patients (27/208), and researcher logs and analysed thematically using inductive coding. Results Enrolment rates for practices and patients were 37% and 25%, respectively. Barriers to GP recruitment were lack of resources and to patient recruitment were difficulty understanding trial material and concern about medicines being taken away. GPs’ primary motivation was perceived importance of the research question, whereas patients’ primary motivation was trust in their GP. All general practices were retained. Thirty-five patients (8.6%) were lost to follow-up for primary outcomes, mainly because they had died and 45% did not return patient-reported outcome measures (PROMs). Conclusion Patient retention for the primary outcome was high, as it was collected directly from patient records. Patient completion of PROM data was poor, reflecting difficulty in understanding trial material. Recruiting older patients with multimorbidity to clinical trials is possible but requires significant resource and planning. Trial registration ISRCTN Registry ISRCTN12752680.

Improving mental health in chronic care in general practice: study protocol for a cluster-randomised controlled trial of the Healthy Mind intervention

“…There are, however, limitations in this study. Firstly, recruitment of general practices for research trials is challenging since they are self-employed often working on a tight schedule [ 36 ]. The study design and remuneration for participation are expected to facilitate recruitment.…”

Screening for Atrial Fibrillation by Digital Health Technology in Older People in Homecare Settings: A Feasibility Trial

“…Older people are often excluded from clinical trials due to advanced age, multimorbidity, and/or frailty [ 1 ]. Recruitment and retention of older participants are important challenges.…”

“…Cognitive decline is common, and proxies or next-to-kin are often needed to consent. Older participants have an increased risk of dropping out of trials, and several other pitfalls may result in both underestimating and overestimating the intervention effects [ 1 ]. Despite these obstacles, it is important to include elderly individuals in clinical trials.…”