Ternary complex formation with solvent
molecules and other adventitious
ligands may compromise the performance of metal-ion-selective fluorescent
probes. As Ca(II) can accommodate more than 6 donors in the first
coordination sphere, commonly used crown ether ligands are prone to
ternary complex formation with this cation. The steric strain imposed
by auxiliary ligands, however, may result in an ensemble of rapidly
equilibrating coordination species with varying degrees of interaction
between the cation and the specific donor atoms mediating the fluorescence
response, thus diminishing the change in fluorescence properties upon
Ca(II) binding. To explore the influence of ligand architecture on
these equilibria, we tethered two structurally distinct aza-15-crown-5
ligands to pyrazoline fluorophores as reporters. Due to ultrafast
photoinduced electron-transfer (PET) quenching of the fluorophore
by the ligand moiety, the fluorescence decay profile directly reflects
the species composition in the ground state. By adjusting the PET
driving force through electronic tuning of the pyrazoline fluorophores,
we were able to differentiate between species with only subtle variations
in PET donor abilities. Concluding from a global analysis of the corresponding
fluorescence decay profiles, the coordination species composition
was indeed strongly dependent on the ligand architecture. Altogether,
the combination of time-resolved fluorescence spectroscopy with selective
tuning of the PET driving force represents an effective analytical
tool to study dynamic coordination equilibria and thus to optimize
ligand architectures for the design of high-contrast cation-responsive
fluorescence switches.