Reconsidering public budgeting after the COVID-19 outbreak: key lessons and future challenges

Abstract

PurposeThe paper aims to offer a viewpoint on how governmental budgeting needs to be reconsidered after the COVID-19 outbreak.Design/methodology/approachBuilding on extant research, and drawing on the Italian context, the paper provides reflections on four interrelated aspects: (1) how budgeting and reporting processes and formats are being modified; (2) how budgeting may enhance governments' financial resilience; (3) how citizens are involved in the budgeting cycles and (4) how emergency responses may produce opportunities for corruption.FindingsTo tackle COVID-19 related challenges, budgeting, rebudgeting, reporting processes and formats need to be reconsidered and supported by the development of new competencies. Governments will need to put stronger emphasis on the anticipatory and coping roles of budgeting to reduce public organizations' exposure to shocks and support governmental resilience. The involvement of citizens has proven critical to face the pandemic and will become increasingly relevant due to the financial impacts of COVID-19 on future public service provision. Greater attention to the risks of increased corruption is also needed.Originality/valueDrawing lessons from one of the countries most hit by COVID-19, the paper offers a viewpoint on a timely topic of international relevance by looking in an integrated way at interrelated topics such as budgeting, rebudgeting, reporting, financial resilience, coproduction and corruption.

Planning for the Unknown: Local Government Strategies from the Fiscal Year 2021 Budget Season in Response to the COVID-19 Pandemic

“…It presents the working assumptions behind the preparation of FY 2021 budgets and the budget balancing strategies employed when revenue shortfalls were anticipated. This research complements recent studies that have begun to explore local government issues around resilience in response to the pandemic, opportunities for innovation, and their accompanying challenges (Maher, Hoang, and Hindrey 2020;Dzigbede, Gehl, and Willoughby 2020;Anessi-Pessina et al 2020). Overall, the data suggest that local governments in North Carolina prepared for a recession by appropriating fund balance and using common cutback-management strategies that have been identified in the literature, like reductions in staffing including hiring freezes and budgeting for no new positions.…”

The relation of COVID-19 to the UN sustainable development goals: implications for sustainability accounting, management and policy research

“…This could have long term fiscal consequences, potentially limiting the ability of governments to intervene in the future (Andrew et al, 2020). Likewise, in the Italian context, concerns have been raised that the increase and the emergency of these spendings might spur corruption (Anessi-Pessina et al, 2020). Future research should assess retrospectively, whether the observed shift in power is temporary or durable and which factors (e.g.…”

Municipal financial vulnerability in pandemic crises: a framework for analysis

“…Observers have highlighted that policy tools used to counteract the impacts of the Covid-19 crisis have had a lot of similarities across countries, even though the sheer financial magnitude of such responses has varied extensively across jurisdictions (de Jong and Ho, 2020). Some municipalities have received funding to support specific Covid19 expenditures, others have been allowed to run deficits, while many central governments have intervened directly to support businesses and families (Anessi-Pessina et al, 2020).…”