In this communication a series of ionic reactions is advanced in order to explain not only indigo blue formation but also the continuous presence of indigo red as companion, and why this compound is always found in minority. Indican is the glycoside found in Indigofera tinctoria from which the mixture of indigo blue and indigo red is obtained by means of air oxidation in alkaline medium. A reaction mechanism for the hydrolysis of indican, which was advanced decades ago, is criticized in this paper. Fifty years ago a radical mechanism was suggested for indigo formation. However, the supposed reactive species, indoxyl radical, was not detected by electron spin resonance. Besides, there is no free radical promoter, and indirubin (indigo red) was not considered. A series of ionic reactions explain the formation of both indigoids, and why indigo red occurs in minor proportion. Indoxyl, 3-hydroxyindole, is the aglycone from indican. Reaction of indoxyl with oxygen is catalyzed by calcium hydroxide, indoxyl hydroperoxide being formed. Internal reaction in this intermediate produces 3-oxoindolenine, which reacts with indoxyl carbanion to give leucoindigo. Further steps lead to indigo blue. Indirubin is formed from indoxyl hydroperoxide by dehydration to isatin, a keto lactam. Condensation of isatin salt with 3-indolinone affords indigo red. This step is retarded due to electric hindrance.