Reasons for transferral to emergency departments of terminally ill patients - a French descriptive and retrospective study

Abstract

BackgroundPatients under palliative care and in hospital-at-home services are frequently transferred to emergency departments.We set out to identify the reasons for these presentations to determine the proportion that might be avoidable.MethodsWe conducted a retrospective study by assessment of patient files.We studied admissions to four emergency departments in an area of France (Puy-de-Dôme) between September 2011 and August 2013. Reasons for transfer and diagnostic conclusion by emergency doctors were noted. We collected date of admission, time spent, investigations and treatments performed and patients’ outcomes after the medical conclusions. We also determined whether patients called the hospital-at-home service before going to the emergency department. From these data we discerned potentially avoidable and unavoidable consultations.ResultsWe identified 52 transfers of patients from home to emergency departments. The most frequent reasons were: generalized weakness (11 cases), social isolation (8 cases) and end of life (7 cases). For 58 % of presentations, the investigations and treatments performed did not require presentation to an emergency department; 34 % of patients returned home after the visit, 41 % remained for simple observation and 20 % remained to receive special care. Two patients died in the emergency department. In 86 % of cases, presentations occurred when primary care was less readily available, and patients called home care services in only 42 % of cases before going to emergency departments.ConclusionsHalf of the transfers to emergency departments were potentially avoidable for terminally ill patients in home care. To reduce this proportion we need to promote access to primary care, educate patients in hospital-at-home service and train care-givers and doctors in palliative medicine.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12904-016-0155-y) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Predictors and trajectories of ED visits among patients receiving palliative home care services: findings from a time series analysis (2013-2017)

“…Indeed, although the benefits associated with hospitalization for patients with palliative care needs cannot be denied [ 5 ], ED visits are considered an indicator of poor quality in home care services [ 6 ]. Moreover, several studies have shown that ED visits in IHPC patients are not essential and potentially avoidable [ 7 – 10 ]. The Italian healthcare system has initiated a shift from institutional palliative care to IHPC, and many efforts have been made to improve the access to and quality of IHPC.…”

Determinants Associated With the Risk of Emergency Department Visits Among Patients Receiving Integrated Home Care Services: A 6-Year Retrospective Observational Study in a Large Italian Region

“…36 Our results showed that, as the distance between the patient's home and the closest ED increases, the risk of ED visits decreases. Coherently with previous studies in France, 37 Sweden, 38 and the United Kingdom, 39 a reduced travel distance can increase the likelihood ED visits, independently of the severity of the medical condition 40,41 thus increasing health costs despite the effective need.…”

Emergency transfers of home care patients in Fukui Prefecture, Japan

“…Previously, Cornillon et al [ 11 ] investigated the emergency transfers of terminally ill patients in France and suggested that only of 52 emergency department visits, 23 (44.2%) contacted HCPs before calling for emergency transfers and that 66% of the cases were admitted or DOA. Although our findings cannot be directly compared with those of the previous study due to the difference of study settings, judgments calling for EMS transfers were generally justified in our study.…”