Reasons for Substance Use: A Comparative Study of Alcohol Use in Tribals and Non-tribals

Abstract

Background:Consumption of alcohol has been attributed to different reasons by consumers. Attitude and knowledge about the substance and addiction can be influenced by the cultural background of the individual. The tribal population, where alcohol intake is culturally accepted, can have different beliefs and attributes causing one to take alcohol. This study attempts to examine the reasons for alcohol intake and the belief about addiction and their effect on the severity of addiction in people with a different ethnic background.Materials and Methods:The study was conducted at a Psychiatric institute with a cross-sectional design. The study population included patients hailing from the Jharkhand state, twenty each, belonging to tribal and non-tribal communities. Patients fulfilling the ICD 10 diagnostic criteria of mental and behavioral disorders due to the alcohol dependence syndrome, with active dependence, were taken, excluding those having any comorbidity or complications. The subjects were assessed with specially designed Sociodemographic-Clinical Performa, modified version of Reasons for Substance Use scale, Addiction Belief scale, and the Alcohol Dependence scale.Statistical Analysis and Results:A significantly high number of tribals cited reasons associated with social enhancement and coping with distressing emotions rather than individual enhancement, as a reason for consuming alcohol. Addiction was severe in those consuming alcohol to cope with distressing emotions. Belief in the free-will model was noted to be stronger across the cultures, without any correlation with the reason for intake. This cross-sectional study design, which was based on patients, cannot be easily generalized to the community.Conlusion:Societal acceptance and pressure as well as high emotional problems appears to be the major etiology leading to higher prevalce of substance depedence in tribals. Primary prevention should be planned to fit the needs of the ethnics.

Increasing use of mental health services in remote areas using mobile technology: a pre–post evaluation of the SMART Mental Health project in rural India

“…Financial problems, illness/injury to self or to someone in the family, and death of a loved one were the commonest stressors associated with moderate/severe depression, similar to earlier research [32]. Lifetime alcohol use had a high prevalence and some reasons suggested for higher consumption among tribal populations are increased poverty, illiteracy, increased stress, and peer pressure [36]. …”

A cross sectional study of alcohol consumption among tribals and non-tribals adults of Narayanganj block in Mandla district of Madhya Pradesh, India

“…4 Manimunda et al also found that alcohol intake with rest of the population was statistically significant in tribal population. 3 Mohindra K also found alcohol consumption in India is disproportionately higher among poorer and socially marginalized groups, notably scheduled tribes (STs).…”

“…3 V. S. Sreeraj, Surjit Prasad, Christoday Raja Jayant Khess and N. A. Uvais, study conducted among the tribal of Jharkhand. 4 NNMB in its technical report no: 24, NIH, Indian Council of Medical Research (ICMR) reported that alcohol consumption were significantly (p<0.001) associated with hypertension among tribal population in their study in nine states of India. 1 Todkar SS et al found a significant association of alcohol intake & hypertension among rural people.…”

Prevalence and pattern of alcohol consumption among males attending primary health care setting using AUDIT in rural Indore, Madhya Pradesh, India

“…Which signals the failure of law system, this finding is in congruent with Meena et al while Sumit et al reported corresponding it as 24 year. 30,21 Basu et al reported as 18 years, while contradictory with deswal et al 34,35 When inquired about reason for alcohol use, 45% explained it for enjoyment and 29.5% were consuming for escaping from pain, work stress as well for social company and 25.2% were due to peer pressure. These findings were similar to study by Ramanan et al in which 44.4% used alcohol for fun while inconsistent findings were reported by Sreeraj et al and Meena et al i.e.…”