Realising benefits in public IT projects: A multiple case study

Abstract

Information Technology (IT) investments in the public sector are large, and it is essential that they lead to benefits for the organisations themselves and wider society. While there is evidence suggesting a positive connection between the existence of benefits management practices and the realisation of benefits, less is known about how to implement such practices effectively. The aim of this paper is to provide insights into when benefits are most likely to be realised, and how benefits management practices and roles should be implemented, in order to have a positive effect on the success of projects in terms of realising benefits. We collected data relating to 10 public IT projects in Norway. For each project, information on benefits management was collected from project documents by interviewing the project owners and benefits owners and via follow-up surveys. The benefits with the highest degree of realisation were those internal to the organisation, while those with the lowest degree were societal benefits. Projects assessed as having more specific, measurable, accountable, and realistically planned benefits were more successful in terms of realising benefits. Benefit owners were most effective when they were able to attract attention to the benefits to be realised, had a strong mandate, and had the domain expertise.

Smidigere oppstart av smidig IT-utvikling i offentlig sektor

“…Det er imidlertid ikke likegyldig hvordan nyttestyringsplanene er utformet. Nytteeffekter bør (se Holgeid et al, 2023) formuleres slik at de egner seg som styringsobjekter. I saerlig grad synes det å vaere viktig at nytteeffekt er formulert slik at det er mulig å evaluere og få tilbakemelding på i hvilken grad ønsket effekt vil bli eller er blitt realisert.…”