Real World Effectiveness of Information and Communication Technologies in Disaster Relief: A Systematic Review

Abstract

Background: The application of information and communication technologies (ICTs) in disaster relief is increasingly widespread, but it is still unclear whether ICT can reduce casualties and economic losses in disaster response phase.
 Methods: We searched studies in the databases of Scopus, EI, MEDLINE and EMBASE from Jan 1, 1990, to Mar 22, 2019. Excel 2016 and VOSviewer (version 1.6.11) were used to analyze the extracted data and visualize the network diagram.
 Results: We included 169 eligible articles. The number of ICTs-related disaster-relief articles published annually shows an overall trend of growth since 1990. The United States has the greatest influence in this field. The 169 articles reported twenty-four technologies and the top three reported most frequently were remote sensing, social media, and geographic information system (GIS). The main roles of ICTs in natural disaster rescue included information dissemination, post-disaster image collection and damage assessment. However, of the 169 articles, only five reported that ICTs reduced casualties or economic losses in disaster response phase, two concluded that rescue robot was ineffective in mudslide rescue, and the remaining 162 (95.86%) did not evaluate the effect of ICTs on the rescue.
 Conclusion: ICTs have the potential to reduce casualties and economic losses, but some technologies are not applicable to all rescue scenarios. In addition, most studies did not pay attention to the effect of technology on the rescue.

Mapping Undermined Role of Information and Communication Technologies in Floods

“…An extensive published literature (Bingqing et al, 2020) is available on ICTs, disasters and transport systems exclusively, yet these three fully developed research areas are not placed in a perspective together to understand their inter-linkages and combined effect to find a defined solution for transport and floods situation through ICTs. Also, there remains many unattended variables that significantly impact the choice of ICTs in floods, such as dependency status of a person, installed ICT in a vehicle, trust on flood managing authorities etc (Yamano et al, 2020).…”

Evaluating The Effectiveness of Information and Communication Technologies (Icts) in Fire Response in Disaster Management in Batam, Indonesia

“…Research has also highlighted the co-evolution of civic engagement and the application of webbased ICTs in disaster response Additionally, ICTs have been recognized for their significant role in preparing for and managing both human-induced and nature-induced disasters. Though, there is still a need for further investigation into the real-world effectiveness of ICTs in reducing casualties and economic losses during disaster response (Lu et al, 2020). ICTs serve as critical tools for supporting effective communication, decision-making, and cognitive capacity in complex and uncertain disaster situations ICTs enhance situational awareness by facilitating real-time data collection, analysis, and visualization.…”