Reading comprehension precursors: Evidence of the simple view of reading in a transparent orthography

Abstract

The Simple View of Reading (SVR) proposes that reading comprehension depends on two general processes –language comprehension and word recognition– and that the contribution of these known processes to reading comprehension varies in time. Specifically, the contribution of word recognition decreases, and the contribution of language comprehension increases with student progress. The purpose of this study was to test the SVR in a large sample of 4,750 Dominican public-school students from second (n = 2,399) and fourth grade (2,351) and determine the contribution of phonological awareness within the SVR. The study found that word recognition and language comprehension explained 80% of the variance in reading comprehension regardless of grade. A quantile regression showed that, as reading comprehension progresses, language comprehension’s predictive power increases, and word recognition’s predictive power decreases. A structural equation model conducted on each grade separately showed that the contribution of word recognition toward reading comprehension remained stable between second and fourth grade. This means that, although the dynamism of the SVR components follows the same pattern reported in the literature, the students evaluated here might reach reading automaticity later than expected. Therefore, more attentional resources need to be allocated toward decoding. The study found that the contribution of phonological awareness toward word recognition increases from second to fourth grade, confirming that students are taking longer than expected to obtain reading automaticity and still going through an overt effortful decoding stage rather than a covert phonological recoding stage, making reading more effortful.

External validity of a reading intervention for primary education as shown in Dominican sixth grade students performance on the National Diagnostic Evaluation

“…Project USAID-Read provides additional information on how this cognitive process takes place in this context by having conducted multiple studies on reading comprehension precursors. These studies have not only validated the project's efficacy (Sánchez-Vincitore et al, 2020) but have also provided support for the simple view theory of reading and described the predictive weights of each subcomponent of reading comprehension (Sánchez-Vincitore et al, 2022).…”