Catalytic dehydration of biomass-derived methyl lactate to produce acrylic acid and its esters promises a renewable route to produce a major commodity chemical. Alkali metal cation exchanged zeolites are capable of catalyzing this reaction, however, selectivity control toward the dehydration pathway remains a challenge. Through combined kinetic and transmission spectroscopic investigations, we demonstrate that introducing pyridine, a base, to the reaction feed increases selectivity to acrylates while inhibiting the formation of side products (i.e. acetaldehyde and coking). The ratio of the turnover frequencies for the desired dehydration and undesired decarbonylation pathways (TOF DH /TOF AD ) increases by a factor of ~20 when pyridine is included in the feed (pyridine/methyl lactate = 1/10), as compared to the case where pyridine is absent. Transmission FTIR investigations show that the reduced decarbonylation activity can be directly related to pyridine quenching Brønsted acid sites generated during the reaction, which are identified as the active sites for the decarbonylation pathway. Exposing NaY to pyridine prior to reaction does not impact the product distribution because Brønsted acid sites are produced by ion-exchange between NaY and reactants. In contrast, exposing NaY to pyridine containing feed for 1 h increases TOF DH /TOF AD after switching to a pyridine-free feed by a factor of ~4, as compared to the case where the catalyst is never exposed to pyridine.