The [Ni0(phen)] (1)-catalyzed
reductive
carboxylation of propyl and phenyl chloride with a CO2 molecule
has been compared using the density functional theory method. The
reactivity of 1 in the initial oxidative addition with
the propyl and phenyl chloride and in the subsequent single electron
transfer step to form the NiI intermediates, [NiI(phen)(R′-CH2)], 4, (R′ = CH3–CH2−), and [NiI(phen)(C6H5)], 4′, is almost the same.
However, an apparent reactivity difference is interpreted in the CO2 insertion step, which involves the NiI and the
NiII intermediates. In both propyl and phenyl chloride,
the NiI-mediated CO2 insertion is kinetically
more preferred than that mediated by the analogues NiII intermediates (3 and 3′) by +5.0
and +33.4 kcal/mol, respectively. This trend in energetics clearly
shows that the CO2 insertion of phenyl chloride exclusively
occurs via the NiI-mediated pathway, whereas in propyl
chloride, it follows both NiI- and NiII-mediated
pathways. Overall, the catalytic efficacy of 1 is found
to be higher in phenyl chloride (by +11.3 kcal/mol) than that in propyl
chloride. Furthermore, the effect of a plausible β-H elimination
side reaction in the CO2 insertion step is modeled for
propyl chloride. Herein, the β-H elimination of the NiII propyl species (3) is kinetically more feasible than
its CO2 insertion, while the β-H elimination of NiI propyl (4) is rather difficult compared to its
CO2 insertion by +16.3 kcal/mol. This strongly supports
the suitability of the NiI intermediate in the CO2 insertion step. In addition, the role of the Lewis acid (X) in the
CO2 insertion step is tested by incorporating various Lewis
acids (X = MgCl2, ZnCl2, AlCl3, and
LiCl) in the NiII propyl (7) and NiI propyl (5) intermediates. The Lewis acids effectively
facilitate the CO2 insertion step, and the effect due to
MgCl2 is found to be more evident. MgCl2 enhances
the CO2 insertion of 5 and 7 by
89 and 84%, respectively, and hence, the NiI-mediated CO2 insertion of propyl halide (ΔG
⧧ = +1.4 kcal/mol) is now comparable with that of phenyl
halide (ΔG
⧧ = +0.9 kcal/mol).
This suggests that in the presence of Lewis acids, the catalytic efficacy
of 1 is enhanced for the reductive carboxylation of propyl
halide and exhibits similar reactivity to that of phenyl halide.