We have investigated the differentiation of paraxial mesoderm from mouse
embryonic stem cells utilizing a Tbx6-EYFP/Brachyury
(T)-Ckerry dual reporter system.
Differentiation from the mouse ESC state directly into mesoderm via Wnt pathway
activation was low, but augmented by treatment with AGN193109, a pan-retinoic
acid receptor inverse agonist. After five days of differentiation, T+
cells increased from 12.2% to 18.8%, Tbx6+ cells increased from 5.8%
to 12.7%, and T+/Tbx6+ cells increased from 2.4% to 14.1%.
The synergism of AGN193109 with Wnt3a/CHIR99021 was further substantiated by the
increased expression of paraxial mesoderm gene markers Tbx6, Msgnl,
Meoxl, and Hoxbl. Separate to inverse agonist
treatment, when mouse ESCs were indirectly differentiated into mesoderm via a
transient epiblast step the efficiency of paraxial mesoderm formation markedly
increased. Tbx6+ cells represented 65–75% of the total cell
population after just 3 days of differentiation and the expression of paraxial
mesoderm marker genes Tbx6 and Msgn increased
over 100-fold and 300-fold, respectively. Further evaluation of AGN193109
treatment on the indirect differentiation protocol suggested that RARs have two
distinct roles. First, AGN193109 treatment at the epiblast step and mesoderm
step promoted paraxial mesoderm formation over other mesoderm and endoderm
lineage types. Second, continued treatment during mesoderm formation revealed
its ability to repress the maturation of presomitic mesoderm into somitic
paraxial mesoderm. Thus, the continuous treatment of AGN193109 during epiblast
and mesoderm differentiation steps yielded a culture where —90% of the
cells were Tbx6+. The surprisingly early effect of inverse agonist
treatment at the epiblast step of differentiation led us to further examine the
effect of AGN193109 treatment during an extended epiblast differentiation
protocol. Interestingly, while inverse agonist treatment had no impact on the
conversion of ESCs into epiblast cells based on the expression of Rexl,
Fgf5, and pluripotency marker genes Oct4, Nanog,
and Sox2, after three days of differentiation in the presence
of AGN193109 caudal epiblast and early paraxial mesoderm marker genes, T,
Cyp26al, Fgf8, Tbx6 and Msgn were all
highly up-regulated. Collectively, our studies reveal an earlier than
appreciated role for RARs in epiblast cells and the modulation of their function
via inverse agonist treatment can promote their differentiation into the
paraxial mesoderm lineage.