I read with interest the article by Sadeghi et al. 1 on the natural history of occult HBV infection (OBI) in children of HBsAg-positive mothers. With the finding that all 17 children with OBI 2 had no detectable HBV DNA after 36 months of follow-up (60-72 months as estimated from the data in the articles 1,2 ), they concluded that HBV DNA positivity early on life (vertical infection) of high-risk children does not necessarily indicate long-term persistence of HBV DNA. However, the results should be cautiously interpreted since the diagnosis of OBI can be questionable. First, 17 children were selected from a cohort with high OBI rate (21/75, 28%). 2 Although Sadeghi et al. cited a report with surprising high OBI rate (64%, reference 7), other studies have shown very low rates (0%-2%) in such populations. 3-5 Second, numerous studies demonstrated that 60%-80% of OBI cases are anti-HBc positive, because HBcAg is most antigenic and anti-HBc may persist for decades. The finding of only one (5.9%) OBI patient being positive for anti-HBc in the article 1 is exceptional. Although four other children had anti-HBc when initially tested, the antibody may have been derived from their mothers, since they were just 10-16 months old 2 and maternal anti-HBc in infants may persist up to 24 months. Third, OBI is a consequence of resolved HBV infection, mainly due to the long-lasting cccDNA form of HBV in hepatocytes. The results that all 17 OBI children became HBV DNA negative indicate clearance of cccDNA in hepatocytes within several years. This is against the rule that cccDNA can persist in patients for decades.Fourth, based on the sequencing data from these OBI children, 2 many children had the same mutations, suggesting the likelihood of same infection source. However, the most possible infection source in these children should be their HBsAg-positive mothers. Thus, homology comparisons of sequences between child-mother pair and between the children would be of great importance to ascertain whether the positive HBV DNA was a true OBI case or occult cross-contamination 3 ; such critical data were not provided. 2 In real-life practice, imperceptible cross-contamination may sometimes occur in performing PCR. 3 Therefore, the diagnosis of OBI should be ascertained before studying the natural history of OBI. Otherwise, the results would be misleading. REFERENCES 1. Sadeghi A, Yahyapour Y, Poortahmasebi V, et al. Clearance of HBV DNA in immunized children born to HBsAg-positive mothers, years after being diagnosed with occult HBV infection. J Viral Hepat. 2016;23:282-285. 2. Shahmoradi S, Yahyapour Y, Mahmoodi M, Alavian SM, Fazeli Z, Jazayeri SM. High prevalence of occult hepatitis B virus infection in children born to HBsAg-positive mothers despite prophylaxis with hepatitis B vaccination and HBIG.