“…Some kilohertz QPOs have relative widths δν QPO /ν QPO 0.005 (see [6,69,96,97,4,5,101]) and the accretion luminosity of a neutron star is typically ∼ 5 times the accretion luminosity of the entire disk [67]. Consequently, even if the emission from the annulus were 100% modulated at the frequency of the kilohertz QPO, which is very unlikely, the relative amplitude of the QPO would be only ∼ 0.005×1/6 ∼ 0.08%, much less that the 2-60 keV relative amplitudes ∼ 15% observed in many kilohertz QPO sources (see, e.g., [69,96,97,101]). …”