Randomised Controlled Trial on the Use of Acupuncture in Adults with Chronic, Non-Responding Anxiety Symptoms

Abstract

Background A group of adults can be identified with chronic non-responding anxiety symptoms who have repeatedly accessed treatments through their GP, such as cognitive behaviour therapy, bibliotherapy and medication, but with no effect. These patients make heavy use of health service resources with no beneficial outcome. This study aims to test the effect of an acupuncture formula of three specific acupuncture points, suggested in a previous pilot study. Method 40 participants from a psychiatry waiting list were randomised into one of two groups: group 1 (n=25) received 10 weeks of acupuncture at PC6, HT7 and LR3, and group 2 was a waiting list control group. The waiting list group (n=15) then received acupuncture. Both groups were followed up for 10 weeks after treatment. The outcome measure was the State and Trait Anxiety Inventory. Results 36 patients completed the study, with two dropouts in each group. State anxiety scores in the acupuncture group decreased from 57.7 (SD 13.1) to 38.8 (12.0); scores in the waiting list control group decreased from 61.5 (11.6) to 60.6 (11.7). The difference was highly significant (p<0.0001). Similar changes were seen for trait anxiety scores. The control group showed similar statistically significant improvements when they received acupuncture. The improvements were maintained after 10 weeks of follow-up in each group. Conclusions Acupuncture is a promising intervention for patients with chronic anxiety symptoms that have proven resistant to other forms of treatment.

How to prove that your therapy is effective, even when it is not: a guideline

“…Consequently, users of many therapies are happy with the outcomes as they have improved, and the deliverers of the treatment are inclined to think that it is the intervention that caused the improvement. This could be an explanation why many interventions, including exotic ones, such as acupuncture (Wu et al 2012;Boyuan et al 2014;Rafiei et al 2014;Errington-Evans, 2015), swimming with dolphins (Fiksdal et al 2012) or other animal-assisted therapies (Kamioka et al 2014a), horticultural therapy (Kamioka et al 2014b) or dancing Argentine tango (Pinniger et al 2012) can still be considered to be effective by patients and therapists. Jerome Frank suggested already in the 1950s (Frank & Frank, 1991) that the most important effects of psychotherapies were caused by the expectations of the patients, the decision they made to seek help, the suggestion and hope that the specialist who treated them was an expert really capable of helping them.…”

Acupuncture Anxiolytic Effects on Physiological and Psychological Assessments for a Clinical Trial

“…However, there were alternative interventions (e.g., acupuncture) which were less intrusive, less time-consuming, and more economic and hence were better candidates for use in athletes' environment [ 14 ]. Recently researchers administered acupuncture as a treatment that could successfully reduce anxiety or depressive symptoms in clinical populations [ 15 , 16 ]. Acupuncture was also suggested to reduce the anxiety of adolescents in high pressure situations such as surgery, academic examination, or sport competition [ 17 , 18 ].…”

Acupuncture as a complementary therapy for cancer care: acceptability and preferences of patients and informal caregivers

“…Acupuncture provides a possible complementary therapy with the potential to relieve both the side-effects of treatment to the patient [6][7][8][9], and informal caregivers [10]. Acupuncture involves penetrating the skin with thin stainless steel needles on speci c locations of the body [1,6].…”