“…The difference in gel mobility between aminoacylated and unaminoacylated tRNAs is primarily due to the extra positive charge on the amino acid, suggesting that the acid gel assay will be suitable for all tRNAsynthetase pairs+ Indeed, significant gel shifts have been reported for many different intact aminoacyl-tRNAs (Varshney et al+, 1991)+ Although we used a nicked tRNA substrate to improve resolution, it seems possible that the gel system might be improved sufficiently such that intact tRNAs can be used+ Even if this is not possible, it is likely that a fully active nicked tRNA substrate can be found for any synthetase by varying the position of the nick+ Many sites in yeast tRNA Phe can tolerate a nick without altering its global folding (Pan et al+, 1991), and a useful strategy has been published for finding sites in a tRNA that can be nicked without affecting aminoacylation (Aphasizhev et al+, 1993)+ Although unmodified nicked tRNA was used in these experiments, a nick in the specific position of a modified tRNA may be prepared using deoxynucleotide-directed RNAse H cleavage (Hayase et al+, 1990;Lapham et al+, 1997)+ Additionally, whereas nonradioactive versions of all amino acids are readily available, certain radiolabeled amino acids are either unavailable or are not stable over long periods+ The generality of the gel assay can therefore be considered another advantage over the traditional assay+ Finally, one of the greatest advantages of the gel assay is its much higher sensitivity+ By using a [ 32 P]-labeled RNA substrate instead of an [ 3 H]-labeled amino acid, the gel assay can potentially detect as little as 0+01 fmol of tRNA, making it at least 1,000-fold more sensitive than the traditional assay+ A major consequence is that this assay can be used in pre-steadystate kinetics where the enzyme is in excess of the tRNA+ This permits the kinetic dissection of the tRNA binding step from the aminoacyl tRNA release step in the kinetic reaction mechanism+ In preliminary experiments, we have observed aminoacylation of 40 fmol nicked tRNA substrate by 8 pmol AlaRS, suggesting that such pre-steady-state measurements are feasible+ The ability to accurately measure both the first and second steps of the aminoacylation reaction should permit the efficient determination of all the kinetic rate constants of the aminoacylation reaction by redundant steady-state and pre-steady-state methods+ This information will provide a framework for the subsequent analysis of mutant proteins and tRNAs+…”