Random Forests and Cubist Algorithms for Predicting Shear Strengths of Rockfill Materials

Abstract

The shear strength of rockfill materials (RFM) is an important engineering parameter in the design and audit of geotechnical structures. In this paper, the predictive reliability and feasibility of random forests and Cubist models were analyzed by estimating the shear strength from the relative density, particle size, distribution (gradation), material hardness, gradation and fineness modulus, and confining (normal) stress. For this purpose, case studies of 165 rockfill samples have been applied to generate training and testing datasets to construct and validate the models. Thirteen key material properties for rockfill characterization were selected to develop the proposed models. Validation and comparison of the models have been performed using the root mean square error (RMSE), coefficient of determination (R2), and mean estimation error (MAE) between the measured and estimated values. A sensitivity analysis was also conducted to ascertain the importance of various inputs in the prediction of the output. The results demonstrated that the Cubist model has the highest prediction performance with (RMSE = 0.0959, R2 = 0.9697 and MAE = 0.0671), followed by the random forests model with (RMSE = 0.1133, R2 = 0.9548 and MAE= 0.0665), the artificial neural network (ANN) model with (RMSE = 0.1320, R2 = 0.9386 and MAE = 0.0841), and the conventional multiple linear regression technique with (RMSE = 0.1361, R2 = 0.9345 and MAE = 0.0888). The results indicated that the Cubist and random forests models are able to generate better predictive results of the shear strength of RFM than ANN and conventional regression models. The Cubist model was considered to be more promising for interpreting the complex relationships between the influential properties of RFM and the shear strengths of RFM to some extent, which can be extremely helpful in estimating the shear strength of rockfill materials.

From Laboratory to Proximal Sensing Spectroscopy for Soil Organic Carbon Estimation—A Review

“…The Cubist is a rule-based model that is able to generate more comprehensive predictive accuracy than conventional statistical methods with minimized risk of over fitting. It can include various predictor variables (categorical or continuous), and the importance of a variable can be automatically obtained to interpret the variable contribution mechanism in the final predictor model [140]. Deep learning algorithms such as ANN are based on the ability to learn during the training procedure in which they are presented with inputs and a set of expected outputs.…”

Prediction of Ultimate Axial Capacity of Square Concrete-Filled Steel Tubular Short Columns Using a Hybrid Intelligent Algorithm

“…(3) Four supervised learning methods (DT, GP, MLR, and SVM) and a metaheuristic optimization algorithm (PSO) were used for nonlinear regression modeling in this paper. Other advanced MLAs can be introduced to predict the ultimate axial capacity, such as multilayer perceptron [65,66] and random forest [67][68][69]. Some new optimization algorithms can also be used to improve model performance while reducing the operation time.…”

Effective Assessment of Blast-Induced Ground Vibration Using an Optimized Random Forest Model Based on a Harris Hawks Optimization Algorithm

“…The procedure of developing an HHO-RF model is shown in Figure 3. Firstly, the collected database should be divided into training datasets and testing datasets with a ratio of 80% and 20% [60][61][62][63]. Then the Harris hawks optimization algorithm will be used to search the best combination of the number of variables used to grow each try (m try ) and the number of trees (n tree ) in the RF model, and the final RF model will be established.…”