Radiocarbon Dates and the Earliest Colonization of East Polynesia: More than a Case Study

Abstract

ABSTRACT. Over the last 30 yr, there has been an ongoing debate on the dates and modes of the earliest colonization of East Polynesia, namely the Cook Islands, the 5 archipelagos of French Polynesia, the Hawai'i Islands, Easter Island, and New Zealand. At least 3 alternative models were proposed by Sinoto, Anderson, Kirch, and Conte, but interestingly all these models basically relied on the same set of roughly 200 radiocarbon dates on various organic materials from archaeological excavations as far back as the 1950s. Some of the models differed by 500-1000 yr-for a proposed initial colonization around the turn of the BC/AD eras, if not considerably later. By comparing the different approaches to this chronological issue, it becomes evident that almost all known problems in dealing with 14 C dates from archaeological excavations are involved: stratigraphy and exact location of samples, sample material and quality, inbuilt ages and reservoir effects, lab errors in ancient dates, etc. More recently, research into landscape and vegetation history has produced alternative 14 C dating for early human impact, adding to the confusion about the initial stages of island colonization, while archaeological 14 C dates, becoming increasingly "young" as compared to former investigations, now advocate a rapid and late (post-AD 900) colonization of the archipelagos. As it appears, the Polynesian case is more than just another case study, it's a lesson on 14 C-based archaeological chronology. The present paper does not pretend to solve the problems of early Polynesian colonization, but intends to contribute to the debate on how 14 C specialists and archaeologists might cooperate in the future.

Variability in the marine radiocarbon reservoir effect in Muscat (Sultanate of Oman) during the 4th millennium BC: reflection of taphonomy or environment?

“…This is particularly true in arid or semi-arid environments. Charcoals when present can be affected by the so-called "old wood effect" (i.e., inbuilt age and/or storage age) leading to an overestimation of the age of the site (Allen and Wallace, 2007;Della Casa, 2009). Under arid conditions, bone collagen, the alternative support favoured by archaeologists for 14 C dating is rapidly hydrolysed and rarely survives beyond a few millennia (Zazzo and Saliège, 2011).…”

Analysis of the expression and function of BRINP family genes during neuronal differentiation in mouse embryonic stem cell‐derived neural stem cells

“…By around 45,000 years ago, humans had extended as far as New Britain and the northern Solomon Islands in Melanesia but dispersal into the Polynesian islands only began around 3,000 years ago (Kirch,2000). The exact dates and modes of colonisation of the region remain uncertain (Della Casa,2009). It is thought that New Zealand was colonized by about 1200 AD (Wilmshurst et al,2008), with the Chatham Islands settled shortly after this time by individuals originating in New Zealand (Sutton,1980).…”