We present an analytical method for the calculation of shapes of Stark-broadened spectral lines in plasmas, applicable to hydrogen and hydrogen-like transitions (including Rydberg ones). The method is based on the recently suggested quasi-contiguous approximation of the static Stark line shapes [E. Stambulchik, and Y. Maron, J. Phys. B: At. Mol. Opt. Phys. 41, 095703 (2008)], while the dynamical effects are accounted for using the frequency-fluctuation-model approach. Comparisons with accurate computer simulations show excellent agreement.