Quaternary pollen analysis in the Iberian Peninsula: the value of negative results

Abstract

Most unsuccessful palynological work is never published. As a consequence, pollen analysts waste time re-processing sterile sediments, and the available literature exhibits a uniformly positive record of success in pollen extraction. Here we report failures with Quaternary pollen analyses in the Iberian Peninsula; that is, case studies where it was not possible to extract palynomorphs for pollen counting. Both totally sterile and partially sterile sites are considered. Sites and perspectives for future studies are suggested. The majority of the failed studies are openair archaeological and palaeontological sites, caves and rockshelters, but there are prominent cases of success. Peat bogs have provided positive results, but only with sequences formed under continuous sedimentation processes in marshy environments. Lakes are often successful sites, but a multi-core strategy, following the facies change along a transect from the shore to the depositional centre, is recommended for saline lacustrine deposits, salt marshes and lagoons, especially when there is evidence of temporary desiccation. Cave and rockshelter infills should be considered case-by-case, and these sites definitely require a palyno-taphonomical approach to post-depositional processes. Indurated deposits are sometimes surprising in their high pollen concentration, but one must be prepared for sterility. Coprolites have been insufficiently exploited, and offer a great potential, especially those of Pleistocene Crocuta. This article shows that venturing into sediments assumed a priori to be 'difficult', like fluvial terraces, slope deposits, speleothems, cave travertines, and palaeosols, may nevertheless be successful. A

Lithic refitting and movement connections: the NW area of level TD10-1 at the Gran Dolina site (Sierra de Atapuerca, Burgos, Spain)

“…Micro-faunal studies indicate the presence of open, dry land and temperature and precipitation levels higher than those experienced today, as evidenced by small mammals, amphibians and squamates (Blain et al, 2008;Cuenca-Bescós et al, 2010. The results of pollen analyses largely agree with these studies (Carrión et al, 2009;Rodríguez et al, 2011).…”

The earliest cut marks of Europe: a discussion on hominin subsistence patterns in the Orce sites (Baza basin, SE Spain)

“…Coprolites are other source of pollen, but an analysis of several coprolites of P . brevirostris from these sites yielded negative results 64 .…”

Late Holocene ecological history of Pinus pinaster forests in the Sierra de Gredos of central Spain

“…For several reasons, including climatic change and human activities, many peat bog basins of the Iberian Peninsula with potential for palaeoecological research are interrupted before that time (Carrión et al 2009). …”