“…Through these literature searches the applicant identified a total of 37 publications as being pertinent to the health claim: 10 human intervention studies (Kuznicki and Turner, 1986;Lieberman et al, 1987a;Griffiths et al, 1990;Silverman and Griffiths, 1992;Mumford et al, 1994;Smith et al, 1999;Smit and Rogers, 2000;Van Dongen et al, 2001;Wyatt et al, 2004;Smith, 2009), 15 human studies on bioavailability or mechanistic studies (Marks and Kelly, 1973;Newton et al, 1981;Bonati et al, 1982;Blanchard and Sawers, 1983;Lelo et al, 1986;Nehlig et al, 1992;Liguori et al, 1997;Fredholm et al, 1999;Magkos and Kavouras, 2005;Specterman et al, 2005;Seng et al, 2009Seng et al, , 2010Arnaud, 2011;Perera et al, 2011;Smith et al, 2013), and 12 non-human studies (Bunker and McWilliams, 1979;Arnaud, 1985;Schiffmann et al, 1991;Okada et al, 1996;Ledent et al, 1997;Wang and Lau, 1998;El Yacoubi et al, 2000;Fredholm et al, 2001;Yamato et al, 2002;Liu and Gao, 2007;Costa et al, 2008;Botton et al, 2010). The applicant also provided four human intervention studies (Rogers, 2011, unpublished;Smith et al, 2011, unpublished;Kennedy, 2011...…”