Oligonucleotide-based probes offer the highest spatial resolution, force sensitivity, and molecular specificity for cellular tension sensing and have been developed to measure a variety of molecular forces mediated by individual receptors in T cells, platelets, fibroblasts, B-cells, and immortalized cancer cell lines. These fluorophore−oligonucleotide conjugate probes are designed with a stem−loop structure that engages cell receptors and reversibly unfolds due to mechanical strain. With the growth of recent work bridging molecular mechanobiology and biomaterials, there is a need for a detailed spectroscopic analysis of DNA tension probes that are used for cellular imaging. In this manuscript, we conducted an analysis of 19 DNA hairpin-based tension probe variants using molecular dynamics simulations, absorption spectroscopy, and fluorescence imaging (epifluorescence and fluorescence lifetime imaging microscopy). We find that tension probes are highly sensitive to their molecular design, including donor and acceptor proximity and pairing, DNA stem−loop structure, and conjugation chemistry. We demonstrate the impact of these design features using a supported lipid bilayer model of podosome-like adhesions. Finally, we discuss the requirements for tension imaging in various biophysical contexts and offer a series of experimental recommendations, thus providing a guide for the design and application of DNA hairpin-based molecular tension probes.