Quality of diabetes care and health insurance coverage: a retrospective study in an outpatient academic public hospital in Switzerland

Abstract

BackgroundSocioeconomic disadvantage is associated with an increased risk of adverse diabetes outcomes. In Switzerland, a country with theoretical universal healthcare coverage, people without health insurance face barriers in accessing to and in receiving standard quality care. The Geneva University Hospitals (HUG) have implemented policies aiming at reducing these gaps. We compared quality of diabetes care and ambulatory healthcare services utilization among insured and uninsured diabetic patients.MethodsThis retrospective study linked health and administrative data of type 2 diabetic outpatients with at least one HbA1c test performed in 2012–2013 at HUG. Quality of care evaluation relied on processes (annual serum HbA1c, cholesterol and microalbuminuria tesing) and outcomes (HbA1c) assessment. Healthcare utilization was assessed by the number of ambulatory clinical and laboratory visits. Results were stratified by disease course (newly diagnosed versus prevalent diabetes).ResultsOf the 198 patients included, 80 (40.4 %) were uninsured. Both groups underwent annual testing of HbA1c, cholesterol, kidney function and microalbuminuria at comparably high rates and numbers of ambulatory visits did not significantly differ. After adjustments for age and sex, there were no significant differences in serum HbA1c between groups both in those with prevalent or with newly diagnosed diabetes. Initial medical intervention entailed comparable glycaemic improvement after 6 months in incident diabetes among insured and uninsured patients.ConclusionsThis study did not find any difference in quality of diabetes care between insured and uninsured patients in a public hospital enforcing health-equity policies for access to and for delivery of standard diabetes care. It highlights the frontline role of public hospitals in contributing to care delivery equity even in countries with theoretical universal healthcare coverage.

‘Managing scarcity’– a qualitative study on volunteer-based healthcare for chronically ill, uninsured migrants in Berlin, Germany

“…Facilitating access has been shown to improve health outcomes: a study conducted in two immigration ‘sanctuary’ areas (San Francisco Bay; Chicago) showed no differences in clinical outcome and healthcare experiences of undocumented and documented migrants with diabetes 35. This corresponds to findings from a retrospective study in a public hospital in Geneva, Switzerland, enforcing health-equity policies 36…”

Glycaemic control among type 2 diabetes patients in sub-Saharan Africa from 2012 to 2022: a systematic review and meta-analysis

“…Poor socioeconomic conditions (low income, poor education) have been associated with poor glycaemic control due to poor access to adequate care and poor health-seeking behaviors [18,48,87,98,99]. Increasing universal health coverage could address these problems and lead to better outcomes [100]. Factors such as food Fina Lubaki et al Diabetology & Metabolic Syndrome (2022) 14:134 insecurity and depression have been identified as mediators in the relationship between poor living conditions and glycaemic control [98].…”

Health of undocumented migrants in primary care in Switzerland

“…Alternatively, restricting access to the public healthcare system to vulnerable migrants entails higher global financial costs as recently shown in Germany [ 42 ]. Experiences in Switzerland and The Netherlands show that such a scheme is feasible, equitable and effective in regards to the management of chronic diseases [ 43 , 44 ].…”