Qualitative comparative analysis in educational policy research: Procedures, processes, and possibilities

Abstract

In educational policy research, linking specific practices to specific outcomes is an important (though not the only) goal, which can bias researchers (and funders) toward employing purely quantitative methods. Given the context-specific nature of policy implementation in education, however, we argue that understanding how specific practices lead to specific outcomes in specific conditions or contexts is critical to improving education. Qualitative comparative analysis is a method of qualitative research that we argue can help to answer these kinds of questions in studies of educational policies and reforms. Qualitative comparative analysis is a case-oriented research method designed to identify causal relationships between variables and a particular outcome. Distinct from quantitative causal methods, qualitative comparative analysis requires qualitative data to identify conditions (and combinations of conditions) that lead to a particular result; it is context driven, just as many educational reforms must necessarily be. We contend that qualitative comparative analysis has the potential to be of use to educational researchers in investigating complex problems of cause and effect using qualitative data. As such, our aim here is to provide a general overview of the characteristics, processes, and outcomes of qualitative comparative analysis. In so doing, we hope to offer guidance to educational researchers around how and when to use qualitative comparative analysis, as well as recommendations for current educational issues that could be investigated with qualitative comparative analysis.

A comparative analysis of educational administration doctoral programs in the international context: Examples from Türkiye and Canada

“…This study aims to identify, compare, and analyse similar and different characteristics of the selected doctoral programs in different universities in Türkiye and Canada having different educational systems. Therefore, it employs qualitative comparative research methodology, aiming to understand, reveal, and delineate the dynamics of educational policy, plan, and reform initiatives within selected contexts that could positively affect the current view of education from a comprehensive perspective (Bingham, Dean & Castillo, 2019). Due to its structural and contextual characteristics, this study is an example of comparative education research.…”

Do The Textbooks Reflect the Curriculum? A Comparative Analysis of Social Studies Textbooks Taught in Public and Private Sector in Pakistan

“…Exploration is also found in literature to be a significant part of comparative studies so as to maintain the evidence-based approach (Esser & Vliegenthart, 2017;Takwoingi, Leeflang, & Deeks, 2013). Also, for making the comparative account of the educational policies explorative type of studies are found to provide best outcomes (Bingham, Dean, & Castillo, 2019).…”

Policy brief: Learning from Italy to promote sustainability education in Hong Kong

“…Policy implementation is context-specific in nature (Bingham et al, 2019). Therefore, it is more important to learn "what conditions made a policy work" instead of simply borrowing a policy from another country.…”