Two new QCD sum rules for nucleons in nuclear matter are obtained from a mixed correlator of spin-1/2 and spin-3/2 interpolating fields. These new sum rules, which are insensitive to the poorly known four-quark condensates, provide additional information on the nucleon scalar self-energy. These new sum rules are analyzed along with previous spin-1/2 interpolator-based sum rules which are also insensitive to the poorly known four-quark condensates. The analysis indicates consistency with the expectations of relativistic nuclear phenomenology at nuclear matter saturation density. However, a weaker density dependence near saturation is suggested. Using previous estimates of in-medium condensate uncertainties, we find M * = 0.64 +0.13 −0.09 GeV and Σ v = 0.29 +0.06 −0.10 GeV at nuclear matter saturation density.