Pupil Dilation and EEG Alpha Frequency Band Power Reveal Load on Executive Functions for Link-Selection Processes during Text Reading

Abstract

Executive working memory functions play a central role in reading comprehension. In the present research we were interested in additional load imposed on executive functions by link-selection processes during computer-based reading. For obtaining process measures, we used a methodology of concurrent electroencephalographic (EEG) and eye-tracking data recording that allowed us to compare epochs of pure text reading with epochs of hyperlink-like selection processes in an online reading situation. Furthermore, this methodology allowed us to directly compare the two physiological load-measures EEG alpha frequency band power and pupil dilation. We observed increased load on executive functions during hyperlink-like selection processes on both measures in terms of decreased alpha frequency band power and increased pupil dilation. Surprisingly however, the two measures did not correlate. Two additional experiments were conducted that excluded potential perceptual, motor, or structural confounds. In sum, EEG alpha frequency band power and pupil dilation both turned out to be sensitive measures for increased load during hyperlink-like selection processes in online text reading.

Is This Information Source Commercially Biased? How Contradictions Between Web Pages Stimulate the Consideration of Source Information

“…Participants' selfreported prior knowledge about nutritional supplements was quite low, whereas their expectations regarding the effectiveness of nutritional supplements were quite positive. Participants' reading comprehension scores were comparable to those of other university samples (e.g., Scharinger, Kammerer, & Gerjets, 2015).…”

The power of neural oscillations to inform sentence comprehension: A linguistic perspective

“…Röhm et al () and Scharinger et al () investigated oscillatory activity elicited by increased processing demands, which was achieved by adding a semantic task (finding a superordinate category) to a simple reading condition, and simulating hypertext reading (presenting a target word along with two alternative options to choose from), respectively. Both studies found reduced alpha power in conditions with additional processing load during sentence processing compared to baseline reading conditions.…”

“…DEC for successfully encoded relative to later forgotten trials (encoding) areas while processing more demanding sentences is linked to better subsequent memory performance, speculatively as a result of more thorough linguistic processing during reading. Röhm et al (2001) and Scharinger et al (2015) investigated oscillatory activity elicited by increased processing demands, which was achieved by adding a semantic task (finding a superordinate category) to a simple reading condition, and simulating hypertext reading (presenting a target word along with two alternative options to choose from), respectively. Both studies found reduced alpha power in conditions with additional processing load during sentence processing compared to baseline reading conditions.…”

A novel method to monitoring changes in cognitive load in video‐based learning

“…First, values out of the normal range have considered as outliers, so they are turned into missing values. The normal range followed the criteria suggested in earlier studies (e.g., Alnæs et al, ; Scharinger, Kammerer, & Gerjets, ): (a) values over the normal pupil size (i.e., 2.0–7.0 mm), (b) values over the normal pupil dilation according to the cognitive processing demands (i.e., ± 1.0 mm), and (c) recorded data when the distance between the eye tracker and the eye was outside the recommended distance (i.e., 50–80 cm). Only 0.8% of data was labelled as outliers according to the rules.…”