Punctuating “Happiness”: Punctuated equilibrium theory and the agenda‐setting of the Gross National Happiness (GNH) policy in Bhutan

Abstract

Gross National Happiness (GNH), a concept first introduced by Bhutan, has gained immense traction as an alternate development paradigm to GDP toward achieving wholesome global progress. In this paper, we investigate the origins of the policy of GNH, through the theoretical lens of the punctuated equilibrium theory (PET), and when and how GNH came to the national agenda. By focusing on the year 2008, that is, when Bhutan's Government transitioned from an absolute monarchy to a democratic constitutional monarchy, this paper analyses the key events that serve as policy windows and the policy entrepreneurs responsible for agenda‐setting the policy of GNH. We argue there is a major change, such as, the government changing its form from monarchy to democracy, it is a definitive benchmark as to what punctuation means. In addition to providing a definitive meaning of “punctuation” in public policy, we also identify and discuss the key methodological issues in relation PET and offer explanations through Bhutan's policy of GNH to determine policy punctuation and measuring policy change.

Cultural biases, agenda setting, and the regulation of policy processes

“…Like the MSF, the punctuated equilibrium theory originated in the USA and has so far mainly been transferred to other established democracies (Baumgartner et al, 2023;Baumgartner & Jones, 2009;Beyer et al, 2022). Ugyel et al (2024) The last two contributions in this issue shed light on the regulation of policy processes through administrative stakeholders. Looking at bank regulation in Turkey between 2010 and 2016, Coban (2024) investigates how the de facto autonomy of regulatory agencies varies across policy areas within the same policy sector.…”

Air Pollution Governance and Residents’ Happiness: Evidence of Blue Sky Defense in China

“…The Gross National Happiness (GNH) index in Bhutan is a typical representative of this theory and practice. The GNH index is a social development concept that emphasizes the overall well-being of the nation, with a focus on balanced development in both material and spiritual aspects [15][16][17]. The second is the micro-level study of happiness, which is the main focus of this paper.…”