A recent article by Spech, Ferrario, and Tarazi 1 in Hypertension has purported that cardiac function of 17-to 29-week-old spontaneously hypertensive rats (SHR) is subnormal. In contrast, in several studies 1 ' 5 involving independent samples of SHR and normotensive rats we have repeatedly demonstrated a stable phase of ventricular function in this age group. These SHRs with moderate left ventricular hypertrophy represent a compensated phase of hypertrophy since a normal peak stroke volume and peak cardiac output are attained despite the elevated arterial pressure. In our experience, it is only in the most advanced age group (greater than 80 weeks) with severe left ventricular hypertrophy (left ventricular body weight ratio 60% to 100% greater than age-matched normotensive ratio) that evidence for impaired left ventricular pump function can be demonstrated.3 -• Our data support the concept that the naturally developing left ventricular hypertrophy of the SHR demonstrates both a compensated phase of hypertrophy in which the increased mass extends reserve capacity and a late phase of depressed performance despite marked hypertrophy. Spech, Ferrario, and Tarazi suggest, however, that the pressure-induced hypertrophy of the SHR is similar to models of acutely induced pressure overload hypertrophy in which function is depressed even early in the course of hypertrophy.Spech, Ferrario, and Tarazi offer several explanations to account for the discrepancy between their results and those from our series of studies. At the outset, none of the technical factors they mentioned could explain the age-dependent alterations in ventricular performance that we find only in SHR and not in normotensive rats. They suggested that we overestimate cardiac output since we use the internal circuits of the flowmeter to display both mean and phasic flows. We have planimetered the area of phasic stroke volume, and, as expected, the product of this planimetered stroke volume times heart rate equalled the electronically derived mean flow. Also questioned was our use of a balanced electrolyte solution (Tyrode's) as our preload stress. We have found that an infusion of Tyrode's solution at 40 ml/min/kg for 45 seconds produces the desired elevation of left ventricular enddiastolic pressure of 16 to 20 mm Hg. Moreover, filling pressures and systemic hemodynamics return to baseline values within 15 minutes. Our flow probes are calibrated with blood using a range of hematocrits (24% to 48%) that we have found not to alter our flowmeter sensitivity.We take great care to maintain our animals at a surgical plane of anesthesia in which blood pressure is close to preanesthesia levels while at the same time muscle tone is flaccid and noxious stimuli do not elicit withdrawal responses. Maintaining this level of anesthesia requires careful and constant monitoring of 719 hemodynamic variables. The first objective evidence of either excessive anesthesia or underventilation is a reduction in blood pressure, cardiac output, and aortic flow acceleration. Spech, ...