Public health systems in the age of financialization: lessons from the French case

Abstract

Public Health Systems (PHS) are under continuous transformation in line with economic, political, and ideological changes in capitalist economies. The current stage of capitalism is underpinned by the process of financialization, meaning an increasing dominance of financial actors, markets, practices, measurements, and narratives over other agents, including the State. This article examines how financialization has been reshaping PHS, with an in-depth study of the French case. First, we suggest how to incorporate the concept of financialization into the research on PHS transformation. We then apply this concept to reassess the trajectory of the French system from the 1990s onwards. We show the increasing participation of financial capital for long-term, short-term, and infrastructure financing, occupying roles previously fulfilled by the public sector. We then discuss how the adoption of financialized strategies led to shifts in how public actors behave, and the potentially adverse effects for solidarity, stability, and democratic participation.

Can ENGLAND'S National Health System Reforms Overcome the Neoliberal Legacy?

“…22 Financialization in health care services is associated with a growing role for financial actors in social reproduction as they seek new profit opportunities. Research has shown its variegated nature in health systems in Turkey, 23 France, 24 lower-income countries, 25 and England's social care system. 26 Despite variations, some common themes emerge, with financialization associated with growing inequalities.…”

Les transformations du capitalisme hospitalier français – Un secteur aux mains de la finance de marché

“…En ce qui concerne l'hôpital, la dynamique de financiarisation est étudiée par celle de la dette de l'hôpital public qui en étant « autonomisé » et « responsabilisé », a contracté des emprunts toxiques (Juven et Lemoine, 2018, Juven et al, 2019. La dette hospitalière comme l'ensemble de la dette de la Sécurité Sociale fait l'objet d'une financiarisation qui prend la forme « d'innovations financières » (tels l'émission d'obligations) (Cordilha, 2021). Cette politique de la dette renforce le pouvoir des marchés financiers.…”

L’Etat et la santé. Une économie politique du capitalisme sanitaire

“…La financiarisation ne se limite pas à la financiarisation des entreprises privées mais elle s'étend au public (Cordilha, 2021). En France, comme dans d'autres pays, les déficits et les dettes des comptes sociaux sont devenus des placements rentables pour les marchés financiers.…”