Psychotic Experiences and Risk of Violence Perpetration and Arrest in the General Population: A Prospective Study

Abstract

BackgroundIn cross-sectional, general population studies, psychotic experiences have been associated with an increased risk of physical violence perpetration and arrest. However, longitudinal research on this topic is lacking. Moreover, it remains unclear whether subjects with psychotic experiences are also at risk of displaying psychological violence. The present study aims to investigate these associations.MethodThe longitudinal association between baseline psychotic experiences and six-year incidence of violence perpetration and three-year incidence of arrest was studied in a prospective cohort of 6646 general population adults. Logistic regression analyses with varying levels of adjustment were performed in the complete sample and in subsamples stratified by presence or absence of baseline mental disorders.ResultsThe presence of psychotic experiences at baseline increased the risk of physical violence, psychological violence and arrest at follow-up. However, adjustment for dimensional measures of psychopathology and contextual confounders reduced all associations considerably. After adjustment, both clinically validated (OR = 3.59, 95% CI 1.09–11.81) and self-reported hallucinations (OR = 2.83, 95% CI 1.05 7.65) remained significantly associated with physical violence perpetration. Self-reported (OR = 3.06, 95% CI 1.55–6.03) and clinically validated delusions (OR = 3.24, 95% CI 1.47–7.13) were associated with an increased risk of arrest. There was no significant association between psychotic experiences and incident psychological violence in the fully adjusted model.ConclusionSpecific psychotic experiences may differentially predict physical violence perpetration and arrest, even after adjustment for demographics, dimensional measures of psychopathology and contextual confounders. However, more longitudinal research with larger sample sizes is required to confirm these findings.

Violent behavior by involuntarily committed female offenders with mental disorders: A population‐based case series

“…A study by Keers et al [37] found a strong association between psychotic symptoms and recent aggressive behavior, since 93% of the patients of his sample displayed psychotic symptoms when they committed these offenses, and 47% were “definitely” or “probably” motivated by these symptoms. Other studies have found an association between auditory hallucinations and persecutory delusions and motivation to commit homicide [38–41]. More severe paranoia is associated with greater aggressiveness, even after controlling for factors as impulsiveness, command hallucinations, treatment with antipsychotics, substance abuse, age, and gender [42].…”

The interplay of psychosis and victimisation across the life course: a prospective study in the general population

“…Sexual victimisation included unwanted touching, forced undressing and forced sexual activity. Consistent with previous work [ 7 , 36 ], psychological victimisation was defined present if it occurred on two or more occasions, and violent/sexual victimisation on one or more occasions.…”

“…One possible explanation is that individuals with PE display disordered behaviour, for example arising from paranoid delusions, leading to social conflict and victimisation. Previous research showed that PE increase the risk of violence perpetration [ 36 ]. Therefore, it is possible that adult victimisation occurs in response to violence perpetration.…”

Violent behavior by women involuntarily committed to a forensic psychiatric hospital in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil

“…A study by Taylor 35 found a strong association between psychotic symptoms and recent aggressive behavior, since 93% of the sample displayed psychotic symptoms when they committed these offenses, and 47% were "definitely" or "probably" motivated by these symptoms. Other studies have found an association between auditory hallucinations and persecutory delusions and motivation to commit homicide [36][37][38][39][40] . More severe paranoia is associated with greater aggressiveness, even when controlling for such factors as impulsiveness, command hallucinations, treatment with antipsychotics, substance abuse, age, and gender 41 .…”