Psychosurgery and the Abuse of Psychiatric Authority in Ontario

Abstract

Over the past two decades political and legal decisions have sharply curtailed psychiatric authority. One area in which psychiatric authority has been most limited is psychosurgery. This paper uses archival evidence from Ontario to show how psychiatrists ordered and administered psychosurgery for a wide variety of reasons. In some cases psychosurgery was administered to ease staffing problems, for experimental purposes, or simply out of sheer curiosity. Often the consent of patients or relatives was not obtained. This egregious abuse of psychiatric authority contributed to the critical movement against psychiatry and to strict laws limiting and sometimes banning resort to psychosurgery.

Review of Abnormal psychology perspectives.

“…However, the text does not shy away from describing some of the more disturbing moments in the history of Canadian mental health, and in so doing it alerts students to significant ethical issues. These developments include the use of psychosurgery during the 1940s, 1950s and 1960s (Simmons, 1987), often used as a method of dealing with patient management problems or to advance research. Simmons documents that well over 60% of all psychosurgeries in Canada were performed on women.…”