Psychometric properties of a culture-adapted Spanish version of AIDA (Assessment of Identity Development in Adolescence) in Mexico

Abstract

BackgroundThe construct “identity” was discussed to be integrated as an important criterion for diagnosing personality disorders in DSM-5. According to Kernberg, identity diffusion is one of the relevant underlying structures in terms of personality organization for developing psychopathology, especially borderline personality disorder. Therefore, it would be important to differentiate healthy from pathological development already in adolescence. With the questionnaire termed AIDA (Assessment of Identity Development in Adolescence), a reliable and valid self-rating inventory was introduced by Goth, Foelsch, Schlueter-Mueller, & Schmeck (2012) to assess pathology-related identity development in healthy and disturbed adolescents. To test the usefulness of the questionnaire in Mexico, we contributed to the development of a culture-specific Spanish translation of AIDA and tested the reliability and aspects of validity of the questionnaire in a juvenile Mexican sample.MethodsAn adapted Spanish translation of AIDA was developed by an expert panel from Chile, Mexico, and Spain in cooperation with the original authors, focusing on content equivalence and comprehensibility by considering specific idioms, life circumstances, and culture-specific aspects. The psychometric properties of the Spanish version were first tested in Mexico. Participants were 265 students from a state school (N = 110) and private school (N = 155), aged between 12 and 19 years (mean 14.15 years). Of these, 44.9% were boys and 55.1% were girls. Item characteristics were analyzed by several parameters, scale reliability by Cronbach’s Alpha, and systematic effects of gender, age, and socioeconomics by an analysis of variance (ANOVA). We evaluated aspects of criterion validity in a juvenile justice system sample (N = 41) of adolescent boys in conflict with the law who displayed various types of behavioral problems by comparing the AIDA scores of a subgroup with signs for borderline pathology (N = 14) with the scores obtained in the student sample using T-tests.ResultsThe psychometric properties of the Spanish version of AIDA proved satisfactory in the Mexican sample for items as well as scales. The reliability coefficients were α = .94 for the total scale “Identity Diffusion”, α = .85 and .92 for the two primary scales “Discontinuity” and “Incoherence”, and between α = .70 and .83 for the subscales. However, some items of the item pool in the Spanish version of AIDA did not meet all criteria for test equivalence and should thus be reformulated, taking the Mexican culture into account. Significant effects for gender and age were found. In line with our theory, the AIDA scores in the domains “Discontinuity” (high effect size) and “Incoherence” (medium effect size) were markedly higher in the delinquent boys than in the student group.ConclusionThe Spanish version of AIDA can be used in Mexico with satisfying psychometric properties, with only minor adaptions required. Our study contributes to the intercultural applicability of the AIDA instrument using the...

An Evaluation of Age-Group Latent Mean Differences in Maladaptive Identity in Adolescence

“…The development of versions in other languages includes cultureadapted translation by experts in the field of child and adolescent psychology, back-translation process and discussion with the original authors and empirical pilot and main tests in school and clinical samples to ensure basic psychometric qualities. Several translated versions had shown excellent internal consistency and construct validity, e.g., among Spanish speaking adolescents in Mexico (27) and English speaking adolescents in the US (28). In the current sample, internal consistency was excellent for the total score (α = 0.94).…”

Reflective function and identity in adolescents with clinical and nonclinical symptoms

“…7 Still, identity consists of two aspects: consistency/inconsistency and continuity/discontinuity. 53 The diffusion of identity is defined as the lack of integration of self-concept from the patient's subjective experience of chronic emptiness and self-perceptions as well as contradictory behavior. 55 There is also emotional instability, lack of personal plans, impulsivity, and difficulties in interpersonal relationships.…”

The role of identity in the DSM-5 classification of personality disorders

“…Reviews of these instruments have recently been published by Bender et al [ 24 ] and Doering & Hörz [ 25 ]. A new self-report instrument with promising psychometric properties has been developed for the assessment of identity pathology in adolescents ([ 2 , 26 , 27 ] this issue).…”