Psychiatry, mental health nurses, and invisible power: Exploring a perturbed relationship within contemporary mental health care

Abstract

Interpersonal relationships, although considered to be the cornerstone of therapeutic engagement, are replete with issues of power; yet, the concept of 'invisible power' within such formal mental health care relationships is seldom explored and/or critiqued in the literature. This paper involves an examination of power in the interpersonal relationship between the mental health nurse and the consumer. Issues of power are emphasized by drawing on examples from clinical experiences, each of which is then deconstructed as an analytical means to uncover the different layers of power. This examination highlights the existence of both obscure and seldomly acknowledged invisible manifestations of power that are inherent in psychiatry and interpersonal mental health nursing. It also identifies that there is an orthodoxy of formal mental health care that perhaps is best described as 'biopsychiatry' (or 'traditional psychiatry'). Within this are numerous serious speech acts and these provide the power for mental health practitioners to act in particular ways, to exercise control. The authors challenge this convention as the only viable discourse: a potentially viable alternative to the current of formal mental health care does exist and, most importantly, this alternative is less tied to the use of invisible power.

‘Because That's the Way It's Always Been Done’: Reviewing the Nurse-Initiated Rules in a Mental Health Unit as a Step Toward Trauma-Informed Care

“…Such distance means that trust can never be afforded in the therapeutic relationship. Nurses have also acknowledged invisible rules that dictate ward cultures and guide routines (Rytterström et al, 2011) and it is arguably these subtle power forces that dictate dominant discourse and rules (Cutcliffe & Happell, 2009). The process of reviewing the rules works to articulate the visible rules in a quest to begin to identify the underlying invisible ones and rebuild trust.…”

“…The open discussions held by the rules review committee about the role of clinical judgement in the implementation of rules, such as access to razors, hairdryers and other equipment, demonstrated a commitment to creating an environment considerate of both emotional and physical safety. Implicit displays of power may insipidly affect inpatient environments (Cutcliffe & Happell, 2009) but the establishment of psychological safety remains a core responsibility of mental health nursing (Björkdahl et al, 2010).…”

A Striving Towards ‘Normality’: Illness-related Beliefs among Individuals Living with a Psychotic Disorder

“…The discourse of recovery with focus on self-determination, dignity and ownership of experiences serves as an alternative to the traditional discourse (Cutcliffe & Happell, 2009). …”

Child and adolescent psychiatric nursing and the ‘plastic man’: Reflections on the implementation of change drawing insights from Lewin’s theory of planned change

“…This in turn may impede their action as a group (Bradbury-Jones, 2008;Cutcliffe, 2009 ;Ryles, 1999 ).This paper proposes that integration of the work of Lewin in the planning of an adoption strategy for CAPN has merit.…”