Abstract:It is increasingly imperative that professional courses produce graduates who are fit for purpose. However, there is evidence that some junior staff within the allied health professions feel ill‐prepared for the demands of contemporary professional practice, especially with respect to their management capabilities. Adverse criticism of new graduates by employers has prompted a variety of curricular innovations. This paper presents the findings of a small evaluative study of the impact of introducing a work‐bas… Show more
“…Evaluations of the final caseload management placement, conducted between 2000 and 2002, identified it as bridging the gap between being a student and becoming an employee, therefore smoothing the transition into practice (Clouder and Dalley 2002). Most importantly, having opportunity to take on increased responsibility headed the list of potential benefits of the module with 61 of the 74 respondents ranking being able to take on increased responsibility highly.…”
Taking on responsibilities associated with a professional role is an important aspect of experiential learning for undergraduate students on work-based placements. However, responsibility is a complex concept that is connected to issues of trust and risk in the placement context. This paper presents students' perspectives that illustrate that being given and taking responsibility can be empowering; conversely, being denied responsibility is disempowering. Through an exploration of the students' experiences, the relationship between responsibility, opportunity, risk and trust is explored. The paper points to a strong indication that the extent to which students are allowed responsibility in the workplace appears to have a fundamental impact on their perceptions of personal efficacy and professional development.
“…Evaluations of the final caseload management placement, conducted between 2000 and 2002, identified it as bridging the gap between being a student and becoming an employee, therefore smoothing the transition into practice (Clouder and Dalley 2002). Most importantly, having opportunity to take on increased responsibility headed the list of potential benefits of the module with 61 of the 74 respondents ranking being able to take on increased responsibility highly.…”
Taking on responsibilities associated with a professional role is an important aspect of experiential learning for undergraduate students on work-based placements. However, responsibility is a complex concept that is connected to issues of trust and risk in the placement context. This paper presents students' perspectives that illustrate that being given and taking responsibility can be empowering; conversely, being denied responsibility is disempowering. Through an exploration of the students' experiences, the relationship between responsibility, opportunity, risk and trust is explored. The paper points to a strong indication that the extent to which students are allowed responsibility in the workplace appears to have a fundamental impact on their perceptions of personal efficacy and professional development.
“…Placement assessment is consistent in terms of mode across all six of these placements. An additional seventh placement that occurs in the final four weeks of the programme, and which focuses on the development of caseload management skills, is assessed differently (Clouder and Dalley, 2002) and is not considered in this study. presentation and punctuality.…”
Given that all of us are potential users of health and social care services, the rigorous assessment of student health professionals in practice should be of common interest. However, rigorous assessment of practice-based learning is notoriously challenging. One would expect assessment in the context of the workplace to be an indicator of fitness for purpose and for practice. However, some indication that health professional students, including physiotherapists, are less fit for practice on qualification than might be desirable suggests a need to rethink assessment practices. Drawing on insights from students, clinical educators, and university visiting tutors in the United Kingdom, this article offers a rationale for combining assessment by observation of performance with a formal oral assessment. We argue that complementarity between the two types of assessment when combined means they allow us to gain a holistic impression of the student's overall performance. We illustrate how the oral component of assessment influences how students go about learning and highlight its perceived 'added value' in terms of helping students prepare for employment. Our findings are theorised in terms of the extent to which assessment aligns with learning activities and learning outcomes, which we believe is vital in health professional programmes. The purpose of this qualitative study was to explore the views of students, clinical educators, and university visiting tutors on assessment strategies used in clinical practice. Our objectives were to develop our understanding of the contribution made by each element of assessment to our overall view of student capability. On this basis we would determine whether both assessment components were deemed necessary by all of the stakeholders.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.