Providers' Reactions to an Automated Health Maintenance Reminder System Incorporated into the Patient's Electronic Medical Record

Abstract

Background: Automated health maintenance reminder (HMR) systems embedded in electronic medical records systems have been found to improve utilization of preventive services, but underuse persists. Our goal was to learn how to make HMRs more effective by measuring clinicians' self-reported use of HMRs and attitudes toward an HMR system embedded in an electronic medical record.Methods: We surveyed 43 clinicians using an electronic medical record with an automated HMR system that prompted the provision of preventive or screening interventions. We measured general attitudes toward computers and the HMR, attitudes toward health maintenance, reactions to key features of the HMR system, and use of information provided by the HMR system; and we asked open-ended responses on how to improve the system.Results: Seventy-five percent of clinicians reported not observing or paying attention to the HMR flashing reminder icon when reviewing a chart, and 62.8% reported they either ignored or forgot to address an alert when it appeared. Only 20% reported regularly reviewing health maintenance needs of the patient before the clinical encounter, and 56% reported seldom or never acting on HMR information during an encounter that was not health maintenance.Conclusions: This HMR system embedded in an electronic medical record was underused by clinicians, causing lost opportunities for provision of preventive care. As electronic medical records become more common, we need to find practical ways that are acceptable to clinicians to use the new capabilities the systems provide.

Prioritizing Paperwork Over Patient Care: Why Can't We Do Both?

“…According to 1 survey at a not-for-profit academic center, the majority of polled faculty physicians admitted to neglecting alerts when they appeared on screen. 34 To date, there are no prospective studies that have assessed alert fatigue among resident physicians. While centralized documentation may be helpful in preventing medical error, a balance has yet to be struck between automated and appropriate notification.…”

Use of an Electronic Clinical Reminder for Brief Alcohol Counseling is Associated with Resolution of Unhealthy Alcohol Use at Follow-Up Screening

“…21,48 It is likely that provider characteristics contributed to whether or not, and how, the reminder was used. 49,50 Finally, because clinical reminder data are only stored locally in the VA, the evaluation relied on merging local data with national clinical and administrative data, limiting the ability of this study to compare changes in AUDIT-C scores at this site with other sites. Despite these limitations, this study has noteworthy strengths.…”

Designing healthcare information technology to catalyse change in clinical care

“…Unfortunately, the majority of clinicians report simply ignoring flashing reminder icons when reviewing a patient's chart during a visit. 55 Many have concluded that computerised reminder systems are underutilised primarily because of competing physician demands during the clinical encounter. 56 If a CR does not fit within the visit's agenda or is otherwise considered a lower clinical priority, there is the risk that the intervention may be overlooked altogether.…”