Concordance of MLL-rearranged acute leukemia in infant monozygotic twins is thought to be 100% with a very short latency period, suggesting that either the MLL fusion itself is sufficient to cause leukemia or that it promotes the rapid acquisition of additional oncogenic events that result in overt disease. We report the first case of discordance in an infant monozygotic twin pair. Twin A presented at age 9 months with MLL-ENL ؉ acute lymphoblastic leukemia and twin B remains healthy 3 years later.
IntroductionReported concordance rates for acute leukemia in monozygotic twins range from less than 5% to 100%, depending on the age of twin A at diagnosis and the cytogenetics of the leukemia. 1 Many reports of twin concordance have documented identical, clonal, nonconstitutional fusion sequences in both twins, suggesting that in these cases a preleukemic clone developed during the prenatal period in one twin and was transferred to the other by placental anastomoses. 2,3 Up to 80% of infant leukemias possess rearrangement of the MLL gene at 11q23, most commonly fused with the AF4, ENL, or AF9 genes. 4 These leukemias have a very short latency period, with diagnosis occurring at an average age of 6 months. Although the number of reported cases is small, the concordance rate for infant monozygotic twins with MLL-rearranged (MLL-R) leukemia is thought to be 100%. 1 The rapid transition to leukemia (which is also seen in therapy-associated MLL-R leukemias) and high twin concordance have led some to speculate that MLL fusions alone are sufficient for the development of leukemia. This view is supported by recent studies showing a striking paucity of copy number alterations (CNAs) in cases of MLL-R acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL) compared with other leukemias. 5 However, data from MLL-R transgenic murine models strongly suggest that additional events are required for the development of leukemia. 6,7 Others have suggested that MLL fusions may promote genetic instability, rapid clonal expansion, epigenetic events, or defective DNA damage repair, leading to the rapid development of disease. 1 It is possible that such events are undetectable at the resolution of the CNA studies.The concordance rate for leukemia in monozygotic twins in childhood (index case older than 1 year) is much lower (approximately 10%). 1 There is often a long latency period, as seen in a set of twins with ETV6/RUNX1 ALL diagnosed at 5 and 14 years of age. Retrospective analysis of bone marrow from the second twin showed the presence of clonal ETV6/RUNX1 ϩ cells at the time of diagnosis of the sibling 9 years earlier. 8 Many childhood leukemias are thought to initiate prenatally. Retrospective analyses of neonatal blood spots from children diagnosed with leukemia years later have shown the presence of cells with identical clonal fusion sequences. This phenomenon is especially common in younger children with a t(12;21) ETV6/RUNX1 translocation or hyperdiploidy and is distinctly uncommon in cases in older children or those with a t(1;19) E2A/PBX1 transl...