Recently developed soft materials exhibit nonlinear wave propagation with potential applications for energy trapping, shock mitigation and wave focusing. We address finitely deformed materials subjected to combined transverse and axial impacts, and study the resultant nonlinear waves. We determine the dependency of the induced motion on the impact, pre-deformation and the employed constitutive models. We analyze the neo-Hookean constitutive model and show it cannot capture shear shocks and tensile-induced shocks, in contrast with experimental results on soft materials. We find that the Gent constitutive model predicts that compressive impact may not be sufficient to induce a quasi-pressure shock-yet it may induce a quasi-shear shock, where tensile impact can trigger quasi-pressure shock-and may simultaneously trigger a quasi-shear shock, in agreement with experimental data. We show that the tensile impact must be greater than a calculated threshold value to induce shock, and demonstrate that this threshold is lowered by application of pre-shear.