Promoting Third Graders’ Executive Functions and Literacy: A Pilot Study Examining the Benefits of Mindfulness vs. Relaxation Training

Abstract

Research suggested that developing mindfulness skills in children improves proximal outcomes, such as attention and executive functions, as well as distal outcomes, such as academic achievement. Despite empirical evidence supporting this claim, research on the benefits of mindfulness training in child populations is scarce, with some mixed findings in the field. Here, we aimed to fill in this gap, by examining the effects of a mindfulness training on third graders’ proximal and distal outcomes, namely, attention and executive functions (viz., inhibitory control, working memory, and cognitive flexibility) as well as literacy-related achievement (viz., handwriting fluency, text quality, Portuguese grades). These outcomes were measured with behavioral tasks and teacher ratings. Sixty-six Portuguese children were randomly allocated to an experimental group receiving mindfulness training (n = 29) or an active control group receiving relaxation training (n = 37). Both training programs were implemented by psychologists in two 30-min weekly sessions for 8 weeks. All students were assessed before and after the interventions. Three main findings are noteworthy: (a) mindfulness training enhanced teacher-rated cognitive flexibility and a performance-based composite score of executive functions among children with higher pretest scores; (b) relaxation training improved performance-based cognitive flexibility and the composite score of executive functions among children with lower pretest scores; (c) children receiving mindfulness training had higher handwriting fluency and better grades in Portuguese than those receiving relaxation training. These findings provide preliminary evidence on the benefits of mindfulness training in educational settings and highlight the moderating role of baseline performance on those benefits.

The role of transcription and executive functions in writing: a longitudinal study in the transition from primary to intermediate Grades

“…Thus, there is a need to introduce complementary curricular programs to stimulate these skills. For example, these programs can focus on self-regulation in the classroom (such as the "Sarilhos do Amarelo" program developed by Rosário et al, 2012, for the Portuguese context) or target mindfulness skills, which have been found to be associated with enhanced EFs and literacy-related skills (Bakosh et al, 2015), including in Portuguese children (Cordeiro et al, 2021). Overall, in spite of the transcription and EFs progress observed here, there is ample room for improvement through additional instructional programs.…”

Protocol of a randomized controlled trial to investigate the efficacy and neural correlates of mindfulness-based habit reversal training in children with Tourette syndrome

“…Mindfulness training can improve performance in attention, working memory and cognitive control tasks ( 55 – 57 ). With the potential benefits of mindfulness in children with common neurodevelopmental disorders ( 58 ), more research has been conducted in recent years.…”

Mindful schools: Neuropsychological performance after the implementation of a mindfulness-based structured program in the school setting

“…Executive functions encompass domain general cognitive processes associated with working memory, inhibitory control, and attention shifting, and are core contributors to school success (Blair, 2016). The scarce research to date suggests that mindfulness-based interventions are a promising approach to targeting attention and executive function in children and adolescent (Mak et al, 2018), indicating that children who are more mindful are also less likely to experience difficulties with inhibitory control, working memory, and attention shifting (Cordeiro et al, 2021;Geronimi et al, 2020).…”