Promiscuous drugs compared to selective drugs (promiscuity can be a virtue)

Abstract

BackgroundThe word selectivity describes a drug's ability to affect a particular cell population in preference to others. As part of the current state of art in the search for new therapeutic agents, the property of selectivity is a mode of action thought to have a high degree of desirability. Consequently there is a growing activity in this area of research.Selectivity is generally a worthy property in a drug because a drug having high selectivity may have a dramatic effect when there is a single agent that can be targeted against the appropriate molecular-driver involved in the pathogenesis of a disease. An example is chronic myeloid leukemia (CML). CML has a specific chromosomal abnormality, the Philadelphia chromosome, that results in a single gene that produces an abnormal proteinDiscussionThere is a burgeoning understanding of the cellular mechanisms that control the etiology and pathogeneses of diseases. This understanding both enables and motivates the development of drugs that induce a specific action in a selected cell population; i.e., a targeted treatment. Consequently, drugs that can target distinct molecular targets involved in pathologic/pathogenetic processes, or signal-transduction pathways, are being developed.However, in most cases, diseases involve multiple abnormalities. A disease may be associated with more than one dysfunctional protein and these may be out-of-balance with each other. Likewise a drug might strongly target a protein that shares a similar active domain with other proteins. A drug may also target pleiotropic cytokines, or other proteins that have multi-physiological functions. In this way multiple normal cellular pathways can be simultaneously influenced. Long term experience with drugs supposedly designed for only a single target, but which unavoidably involve other functional effects, is uncovering the fact that molecular targeting is not medically flawless.SummaryWe contend that an ideal drug may be one whose efficacy is based not on the inhibition of a single target, but rather on the rebalancing of the several proteins or events, that contribute to the etiology, pathogeneses, and progression of diseases, i.e., in effect a promiscuous drug. Ideally, if this could be done at minimum drug concentration, side effects could be minimized. Corollaries to this argument are that the growing fervor for researching truly selective drugs may be imprudent when considering the totality of responses; and that the expensive screening techniques used to discover these, may be both medically and financially inefficient.

Dual EGFR and mTOR targeting in squamous cell carcinoma models, and development of early markers of efficacy

“…A reflection of this is the success of relatively nonspecific agents such as sorafenib or of agents that interfere at multiple levels such as bortezomib. Some authors advocate the development of 'magic shotguns' rather than 'magic bullets' as a more realistic and potentially successful approach to tackle a disease of such complexity as cancer (Mencher and Wang, 2005). Combining targeted agents is another rational strategy capable to induce tumour regressions in tumour models, as previously reported (Jimeno et al, 2005).…”

Curcumin as “Curecumin”: From kitchen to clinic

“…Extensive research over the last half century has made clear that most chronic illnesses can only be cured by multitargeted, as opposed to mono-targeted, therapy [204][205][206] and that promiscuous targeting of a disease cell's multiple bypass mechanisms is a therapeutic virtue [207]. Consequently, agents that can modulate multiple cellular targets are now attractive objects of research.…”

Development of Novel Broad Spectrum Anticancer Small Molecule Peptidomimetics with Nanomolar Activity

“…We support the concept that the ideal drug maybe a broad spectrum drug whose efficacy is based not on the inhibition of a single target but rather a multi-targeted drug that affects several proteins or events that contribute to the etiology, pathogenesis and progression of diseases [2]. In addition, multipathway targeting is one of the strategies to overcome chemo-resistance.…”