Professional identity formation of medical students: A mixed-methods study in a hierarchical and collectivist culture

Abstract

Background Professional identity formation (PIF) has been recognized as an integral part of professional development in medical education. PIF is dynamic: it occurs longitudinally and requires immersion in the socialization process. Consequently, in the medical education context, it is vital to foster a nurturing learning environment that facilitates PIF. Aim This study assesses PIF among medical students in various stages of study and explores their perceptions of PIF, with its contributing and inhibiting factors. Method This mixed-methods study uses a sequential explanatory approach with undergraduate (years 2, 4, and 6) and postgraduate medical students in Indonesia. We examine the subjects by administering an adapted questionnaire on PIF. We completed a series of FGDs following questionnaire administration. Quantitative and thematic analyses were conducted sequentially. Results & Discussion A total of 433 respondents completed the questionnaire. There were statistically significant differences among subjects on the subscales “Recognition and internalization of professional roles” and “Self-control in professional behavior”; the more senior students had higher scores. We conducted 6 FGDs in total. The results characterize PIF as a complex, dynamic, and longitudinal journey to becoming a medical doctor that is closely related to a student’s motivation. The FGDs also highlight the importance of both internal factors (students’ values, attributes, and personal circumstances) and external factors (curriculum, the learning environment, workplace-based learning, and external expectations) for PIF in medical education. Conclusion Higher-level students show higher scores in some aspects of PIF, which further validates the potential use of the questionnaire to monitor PIF, a dynamic process influenced by internal and external factors. Generating awareness among medical students and encouraging reflection on their PIF stage may be crucial for PIF processes.

The Importance of Learning with Patients: Post-Pandemic Takeaways on Learning Professionalism in Clinical Settings

“…Considering the evidence, this study revealed the need for an explicit professionalism curriculum in clinical learning ( 15 , 19 , 23 , 29 ). The literature explained that learning professionalism has not been explicit in medical education, making it harder to prioritise professionalism in teaching, learning and assessment ( 19 , 30 ).…”

“…Thus, offline sessions were limited in time and did not provide a variety of cases, making it even harder for students to interact with patients and learn professionalism ( 26 , 27 ). The lack of interactions with patients resulted in anxiety and a loss of confidence about student competence ( 15 , 19 ). This finding highlights the importance of direct patient interactions and the clinical learning environment in learning professionalism ( 26 ).…”

“…A study conducted in the hierarchical culture context showed that students agreed that the curriculum is an important aspect of professional identity formation. It was further highlighted that the explicit teaching and assessment of professionalism, a supportive and nurturing learning environment and workplace-based learning—to some extent—affected students’ professional development ( 15 ). As medical students are the main stakeholders in medical education, they play essential roles in developing medical school curricula, including the appraisal of the existing curriculum related to professional development during the clinical stage.…”

The Influence of Professional Identification and Organizational Incentives on Turnover Intentions: A Hierarchical Linear Model in Beijing's Family Doctors

“…Most scholars believe that the cultivation of professional identity does not only derive from organizational behavior and individual thoughts, but it is largely initially formed during the stages of education and learning. Therefore, efforts to enhance and cultivate professional identity should commence from educational institutions [33].…”

Evaluating the Impact of the National Health Service Digital Academy on Participants’ Perceptions of Their Identity as Leaders of Digital Health Change: Mixed Methods Study

“…Professional identity formation has become the focus of a diverse range of fields, including medical education [ 26 ]. Among health care professionals, studies have shown that the development of a shared core value set can have substantial benefits, including improving the well-being and resilience of physicians [ 27 ].…”