Process-Based Species Action Plans: an approach to conserve contemporary evolutionary processes that sustain diversity in taxonomically complex groups

Abstract

Many endemic plant species belong to taxonomically complex groups. These endemics have often arisen as a consequence of recent and rapid evolutionary divergence facilitated by processes such as hybridization, polyploidy and/or breeding system transitions. The rapid and dynamic nature of divergence in taxonomically complex groups leads to problems in the implementation of traditional species-based approaches for the conservation of the biodiversity that they contain. Firstly, the taxa of interest can be difficult to define and identify, leading to practical difficulties in implementing conservation measures. Secondly, a species-based approach often fails to capture the complexity of diversity present in the taxonomically complex group. To accommodate these challenges, we have developed a Process-Based Species Action Plan approach. This is designed to conserve the processes leading to the generation of biodiversity, rather than focusing on the preservation of individual named taxa. We illustrate the approach using a group of endemic tree species (Sorbus) on the Scottish island of Arran that have originated via a combination of multiple recent hybridization events and apomixis. The plan focuses on the optimization of habitat management to ensure the reproduction and regeneration of Sorbus in the zone in which these evolutionary processes operate, and to facilitate hybridization that will ensure the continued generation of diversity in this groupPeer reviewe

Comparison of pollen grain morphological features of selected species of the genusCrataegus(Rosaceae) and their spontaneous hybrids

“…The taxonomy of Crataegus is problematic owing to biological and historical factors (Dönmez, ). As in other large maloid genera, frequent interspecific hybridization, extensive polyploidy and apomixes all have the potential to blur the boundaries between species (Byatt, Ferguson & Murray, ; Dönmez, ; Talent & Dickinson, ; Dickinson, Lo & Talent, ; Ennos et al ., ). Christensen () also emphasized that Crataegus has a complicated taxonomic history, because numerous species have been described by several authors and the circumscriptions of the species have varied widely.…”

Application of plastid and nuclear markers to DNA barcoding of Euro-Mediterranean oaks (Quercus, Fagaceae): problems, prospects and phylogenetic implications

“…In addition, the effect of hybridization and biogeography on the diversity patterns of more variable markers ( trnH ‐ psbA and matK ) was discussed. On this basis, Quercus appeared to belong to a ‘taxonomically complex group’ (TCG; Hollingsworth et al ., ; Ennos et al ., ), i.e. a group in which species identifications using a barcoding approach are unlikely because of several limiting factors (hybridization, low mutation rates, complex species history, narrowly defined species limits, etc.).…”

Delimiting genetic units in Neotropical toads under incomplete lineage sorting and hybridization

“…At the core of these discussions is the recognition of species as segments of population lineages against a view of species as operational units of a taxonomic rank [11]. Regardless of the adopted view, most biodiversity researchers agree that delimitation of genetic units is i) a useful proxy for enhancing the rate of taxonomic discovery and ii) the first step towards understanding evolutionary mechanisms contributing to diversification of closely related organisms, two measures that are specially relevant for conservation planning of taxa in threatened environments [12,13]. …”