Probing Alignment of Personal and Organisational Values for Sustainability: An Assessment of Barrett’s Organisational Consciousness Model

Abstract

To what extent are the values of employees and employers aligned in the context of sustainability and how might this be assessed? These are the main research questions in a case study involving a Swedish Small to Medium Enterprise (SME) with ambitions to become more ‘sustainable’. The wider context of the paper is the alignment of managerial and employee values for organisational sustainability. Specifically, the study applies and assesses Barrett’s concept of Organisational Consciousness as a level-based approach to sustainability values, which we argue is based on an integration of Maslow’s hierarchy of needs and Wilber’s Integral metatheory. Quantifying the incidence of references to various values elicited in interviews, the study demonstrates: the limited salience of Barrett’s themes (‘attributes’) for employees; the divergent perspectives in participants’ personal and organisational lives. While normatively affirming Barrett’s overall approach, we observe that most organisations are likely to be a considerable distance from Barrett’s higher levels. How one interprets this is debatable: it may be concluded that Barrett’s framework is overambitious or that organisations need to: (i) broaden their understanding of sustainability and (ii) nurture alignment between personal and organisational values.

Evaluating the Decent Work Scale Measurement Model in Zimbabwe

“…Research affirms the importance of ensuring alignment between individual, community and organisational values (Klapper et al, 2020). A common way to ensure alignment is through corporate social responsibility (CSR).…”

“…As submitted by Duffy et al (2016), the PWT 'may be limited in the extent to which it is generalisable outside of North America and particularly outside of an individualistic cultural framework ' (p.:146). The PWT primarily draws on the formal employment model characteristic of the developed world, the so-called Fordist employment regime that promised stable, secure employment with benefits (Klapper et al, 2020).…”

Unraveling the Sustainability Components of Organizational Value Statements: A Q-Sort Methodology Approach

“…Until recent decades, the literature has begun to emphasize the increasing importance of aligning organizational values with sustainability goals [28] and shaping the ethical position of the organization [29]. Aguinis and Glavas [30] also maintained that the business case for sustainability has underscored the need to integrate ethical and environmentally responsible practices into companies' values.…”

Value Statements and Sustainability: A Q-Sort Methodology Approach

“…Until recent decades, literature has begun to emphasize the increasing importance of aligning organizational values with sustainability goals (Klapper et al, 2020) and shaping the ethical position of the organization (Finegan & Theriault, 1997). Aguinis and Glavas (2012) also maintained that the business case for sustainability has underscored the need to integrate ethical and environmentally responsible practices into companies' values.…”