Private tutoring in a high socio‐economic secondary school in Israel and pupils’ attitudes towards school learning: A double‐edged sword phenomenon

Abstract

Private tutoring (PT) is a widespread educational phenomenon that blurs the conceptual boundaries of public and private education and can affect the formal school system and teachers’ work. This study examined whether participation in PT and the estimation of private tutors’ contributions are related to pupils’ attitudes towards teachers’ effectiveness. Based on a questionnaire administered to all pupils (n = 855) from Grades 7 to 10 from one secondary school located in an affluent area at the centre of Israel (respondence rate, 83.2%), it was found that overall, there were few differences in students’ attitudes between participants in PT compared to those who did not participate in PT. However, among those who participate in PT, their attitudes towards school teachers are related to the distinction between the academic and social‐affective contribution of private tutors. When PT is related to academic spheres, it enhances positive attitudes towards school teachers and when PT is related to socio‐affective aspects, it increases criticism. The findings highlight the complex interactions of PT with mainstream education and emphasise the challenges school teachers face in view of the trend for more personalised learning approaches.

A Place Between School and Home: Exploring the Place of Shadow Education in Students’ Academic Lives in the Netherlands

“…Often, such motives are a reflection of what caused students to turn to shadow education in the first place. Hajar (2018), for example, found that students attended shadow education with the relatively proximal motive of passing school exams, and these findings were consistent across interview studies in Bangladesh (Mahmud, 2019), China (Yung, 2015), Israel (Addi-Raccah, 2019), and Japan (Ozaki, 2015).…”

The association between private tutoring and access to grammar schools: Voices of Year 6 pupils and teachers in south‐east England

“…both tangible and intangible impact of PT). As Addi‐Raccah (, p. 6) remarks, PT should not be perceived as ‘just a supplement that leaves the school system unchanged, but rather PT may challenge schools to take into account new institutional arrangements'. Therefore, influential actors in formal education settings should adapt to changes occurring outside their boundaries, and attempt to address perceived deficits in practice, both pragmatically and strategically.…”