Private-Public Interaction in Global Governance: The Case of Transnational Commercial Arbitration

Abstract

Scholars of international relations and global governance are increasingly interested in the transnational commercial arbitration system. So far, they have tended to characterize the system as a form of private global governance. However, using a combination of empirical and legal analysis, this article draws attention to the critical role of the state in the transnational commercial arbitration system, and shows that both rule-making and enforcement in the system depend largely on interactions between private and public actors. By treating arbitration as a form of private governance, scholars run the risk of obscuring these interactions and hindering their understanding of how transnational economic activity is governed. This article therefore argues for a modest reorientation of global governance scholarship on transnational commercial arbitration in a direction that focuses more closely on private-public interaction. More broadly, this article suggests that understanding interactions between private and public actors is a key to understanding global governance in general, and it raises doubts about the analytical desirability of a sharp distinction between private and public forms of global governance.

Regulation and Economic Globalization: Prospects and Limits of Private Governance

“…34 Mattli and Woods 2009a;2009b. 35 Whytock 2010. between public and private governance, we propose six hypotheses about when and where private governance is most likely to succeed. The first four hypotheses can be thought of as predicting the domain in which we expect to see the most established and effective forms of private governance.…”

Promoting trade through private law: Explaining international legal harmonization

“…This literature largely highlights regulation issued by private firms and organizations. Some have argued, however, that private governance often involves the state and that we should develop a better understanding of the public-private interaction (Whytock 2010). This article contributes to such an understanding, as it focuses on state law that governs private activity and on the tradeoff between private and public law.…”

From International Law and International Relations to Law and World Politics

“…For example, IR scholars are increasingly studying the role of private rulemaking in the regulation of the global economy (Büthe & Mattli 2011) and the impact of domestic and transnational private actors on the evolution and effectiveness of international law (Sandholtz & Stiles 2008;Simmons 2009;Finnemore & Sikkink 1998). They also have started to examine how private actors govern transnational activity through arbitration (Whytock 2010a).…”

“…Just as states use private international law to govern private transnational activity, they use it to support private governance. The key to understanding global governance today is to understand private-public interaction (Whytock 2010a), and a central element of this interaction is private international law.…”