Principles for Valid Histopathologic Scoring in Research

Abstract

Histopathologic scoring is a tool by which semi-quantitative data can be obtained from tissues. Initially, a thorough understanding of the experimental design, study objectives and methods are required to allow the pathologist to appropriately examine tissues and develop lesion scoring approaches. Many principles go into the development of a scoring system such as tissue examination, lesion identification, scoring definitions and consistency in interpretation. Masking (a.k.a. “blinding”) of the pathologist to experimental groups is often necessary to constrain bias and multiple mechanisms are available. Development of a tissue scoring system requires appreciation of the attributes and limitations of the data (e.g. nominal, ordinal, interval and ratio data) to be evaluated. Incidence, ordinal and rank methods of tissue scoring are demonstrated along with key principles for statistical analyses and reporting. Validation of a scoring system occurs through two principal measures: 1) validation of repeatability and 2) validation of tissue pathobiology. Understanding key principles of tissue scoring can help in the development and/or optimization of scoring systems so as to consistently yield meaningful and valid scoring data.

Francisella tularensis Schu S4 Lipopolysaccharide Core Sugar and O-Antigen Mutants Are Attenuated in a Mouse Model of Tularemia

“…Tissue sections were examined, and digital images were collected using a high-resolution digital camera (DP71; Olympus) on a BX51 microscope (Olympus). Scoring of lung tissues was performed following the principles of histopathologic scoring (30). Organs were harvested and fixed as described above on day 4 postinfection.…”

The effects of quercetin on oxidative stress and fibrosis markers in chronic kidney disease rat model

“…Fibrosis was graded by two independent pathologists. To analyze renal fibrosis, we used analysis criteria by Chen et al 12 and Gibson-Corley et al 17 The accumulation of collagen in the interstitial renal cortex was up to 5%, and the renal capsule was not thick. The slightly collagen accumulation (6-25%) accompanied by a thickening of the renal capsule, moderate accumulation of collagen (26-50%) accompanied by a thickening of the renal capsule, and severe collagen accumulation (>50%) accompanied by a thickening of the kidney capsule (sometimes with glomerulosclerosis) were graded as 0, 1, 2 and 3 respectively.…”

Clinical and Histopathologic Characterization of Canine Chronic Ulcerative Stomatitis

“…The histopathologic analysis included examination of routine hematoxylin and eosin (HE)-stained slides as well as special stains for mast cells 17,18 (toluidine blue) and eosinophils (Luna's stain). Immunohistochemistry was performed to identify B-cell (CD79aþ), T-cell (CD3þ), and Forkhead-box protein 3 (FoxP3þ) cell infiltrates.…”