Primary-care providers’ perceived barriers to integration of genetics services: a systematic review of the literature

Abstract

Purpose: We aimed to systematically review the literature to identify primary-care providers' perceived barriers against provision of genetics services. Methods:We systematically searched PubMed and ERIC using key and Boolean term combinations for articles published from 2001 to 2012 that met inclusion/exclusion criteria. Specific barriers were identified and aggregated into categories based on topic similarity. These categories were then grouped into themes.Results: Of the 4,174 citations identified by the search, 38 publications met inclusion criteria. There were 311 unique barriers that were classified into 38 categories across 4 themes: knowledge and skills; ethical, legal, and social implications; health-care systems; and scientific evidence. Barriers most frequently mentioned by primary-care providers included a lack of knowledge about genetics and genetic risk assessment, concern for patient anxiety, a lack of access to genetics, and a lack of time. Conclusion:Although studies reported that primary-care providers perceive genetics as being important, barriers to the integration of genetics medicine into routine patient care were identified. The promotion of practical guidelines, point-of-care risk assessment tools, tailored educational tools, and other systems-level strategies will assist primary-care providers in providing genetics services for their patients.

Primary care providers’ cancer genetic testing-related knowledge, attitudes, and communication behaviors: A systematic review and research agenda

“…Similarly, a systematic review of research published from 2001-2012 concluded that a lack of knowledge and skills, along with attitudes and concerns about patient distress, were common barriers to PCPs integrating genetic services into patient management. 26 This past work confirms that PCPs' knowledge and attitudes are critical to their genetic testing utilization.…”

Primary Care Providers’ Use of Pharmacist Support for Delivery of Pharmacogenetic Testing

“…In personalized and precision medicine, provider knowledge and decision support have been identified as key issues to the integration of new genetic and genomic applications [20]. While some groups are developing EMR-based PGx CDS alerts [21,22] PGx consultation service staffed by a pharmacist and a physician geneticist [23].…”

What is the role of clinical genetics in the patient-centered medical home?: A commentary from the Medical Home Workgroup of the Heartland Regional Genetics and Newborn Screening Collaborative

“…Medical geneticists then need to be cognizant of the PCMH, the patient/family, and their own specific role for each individual case. 8 While this answer may seem a little oversimplified, it truly is the best framework in which to establish the optimal working relationship for patients and their families. In discussions that we have had with PCPs and patients, the most common suggestion is improved communication.…”