Price Formats as a Source of Price Dispersion: A Study of Online and Offline Prices in the Domestic U.S. Airline Markets

Abstract

A large body of research in economics, information systems and marketing has sought to understand sources of price dispersion. Previous empirical work has mainly offered consumer and/or product based explanations for this phenomenon. In contrast, our research explores the key role played by vendors' price-format adoption in explaining price dispersion. We empirically analyze half-million online and offline prices offered by major U.S. airlines in the top 500 domestic markets. Our study shows that a vendor's price-format remains an important source of price dispersion in both channels even after accounting for other factors known to impact dispersion in airline ticket prices. Importantly, this finding is true for both transacted and posted tickets. We document several other interesting empirical findings. First, the lower variance in the prices of EDLP firms serves to reduce the market-level dispersion in prices when such firms are present. Moreover, the price variance of non-EDLP firms in these markets is also lower than in those markets in which EDLP competitors are absent. Second, we also find that dispersion in offered prices increases closer to the departure date, which is consistent with theoretical assertion that price dispersion increases with reservation prices. Finally, we continue to observe dispersion of online prices even after accounting for vendor strategy and other known sources of dispersion, suggesting that the prices are unlikely to converge even in the presence of sophisticated online search mechanisms.

The role of the distribution platform in price formation of paid apps

“…Nevertheless, even after refining our matching procedure by exactly matching also for all app-level decisions variables (e.g., observations of apps offering a free trial version in App Store matched only with observations of apps offering free trial version in Google Play, and so forth), our findings remain unchanged in spite of a considerable reduction in the number of observations (from 3520 to 1520). 13 …”

“…From a theoretical perspective, elucidating the rationale behind the potential emergence of differences in price levels across different online platforms is also particularly relevant for the literature on online price formation. In fact, although price formation across online retailers has been extensively studied in the past decade in the electronic commerce literature [6,9,[13][14][15]27,37,40,55], the insights derived from these studies might not necessarily apply to app stores. Indeed, there exist two fundamental differences, which distinguish app stores from traditional online retailers and thus motivate our study on the role of the distribution platform in the app market.…”

Computational Social Science Fusion Analytics: Combining Machine-Based Methods with Explanatory Empiricism

“…As a discipline, Marketing has relied more on IT, Economics and CS for its data analytics. From channel choice to prices and recommendation systems, music bundling and online reviews, and social networks, interdisciplinary researchers have conducted impactful analytics research [19,28]. Many different sources of data have been used, and there has been substantive mastery of the collection and analysis of Web data.…”

Pricing Strategies in the Electronic Marketplace

“…Again, in the airline market, Chellappa et al (2011) indicate that price formats, namely, ''everyday low price'' (EDLP) and ''promotional pricing'' (HILO/ PROMO), play a significant role in determining price disparity, even after controlling for factors affecting airline price differentials.…”