sponsor. The GAIT ancillary trial was designed to be exploratory, and the hypothesis-generating procedure incorporated the most accurate assumptions about OA disease progression and outcome measures available at the time. Even today, the optimal radiographic measure of disease progression in OA remains a point of debate (2-5). The nonfluoroscopic MTP view utilized in the current study was optimized by the standard use of foot positioning templates at each visit to obtain consistent tibial plateau alignment.After recruitment for the GAIT study began, several studies, including the GAIT ancillary trial, demonstrated that the progression of OA (as assessed by radiographic JSN) was substantially slower than had been assumed when GAIT protocols were developed (6-8). These reports, in part, led to our concerns about the limited power of the current study, as was clearly indicated in our report. Brandt and colleagues voice a concern about statistical precision, but not statistical bias. We agree that precision, due to a combination of slower disease progression and greater variability than predicted, contributed to low power in the ancillary study. We find little evidence to suggest that the nonfluoroscopic MTP view produced bias.Contrary to the assertions made by Brandt et al, we did not report trends indicating that any of the agents slowed JSN. Within the context of the study's limitations, however, the observations we did report are as follows: there was no significant difference in predefined joint space width (JSW) loss between the treatment groups and the placebo group, and regardless of treatment group, knees with K/L grade 2 OA appeared to have less JSW loss and were less likely to progress radiographically than knees with K/L grade 3 OA. In accordance with the hypothesis-generating goals of this ancillary study and the above observations, investigators designing future OA trials evaluating structural modification will need to include planning for a lower rate of progression and a smaller loss in JSW over time than were assumed in past studies.